Why good guys aren’t preferred as tough leaders
September 28th, 2011 - 6:07 pm ICT by IANSWashington, Sep 28 (IANS) When the going gets tough, people prefer a dominant power-hungry guy to lead them, rather than someone good or respectable, researchers say.
Respectable people may be perceived as desirable leaders in peaceful contexts, but they are viewed as submissive when compared to their more self-seeking peers, who can handle conflicts.
“People with high prestige are often regarded as saints, possessing a self-sacrificial quality and strong moral standards,” said study author Robert Livingston, assistant professor of management and organisations at the Kellogg School of Management.
“However, while these individuals are willing to give their resources to the group, they are not perceived as tough leaders,” added Livingston, according to the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.
Researchers define dominance as an imposed “alpha status”, whereas prestige is respect freely-conferred by others, according to a Kellogg School statement.
Al Capone, for example, can be viewed as a high-dominance individual, whereas Mother Teresa exudes high prestige.
“This research begins to explore when ‘nice guys’ finish first and when they finish last, depending on the group context,” said Nir Halvey, acting assistant professor of organisational behaviour at the Stanford Graduate School of Business.
“‘Nice guys’ don’t make it to the top when their group needs a dominant leader to lead them at a time of conflict,” added Halvey, who led the study.
- Power, alcohol, anonymity make you drop guard - Jun 23, 2011
- Why a first impression really is the last impression - Jan 19, 2011
- Rival's deep, masculine voice not enough to challenge a man's dominance - May 29, 2010
- Study finds hemodynamic responses for infant's facial expressions - Nov 06, 2010
- How partners perceive each other's emotion during relationship fight - Dec 19, 2010
- A strong male voice denotes dominance - May 29, 2010
- Scientists dissect anatomy of conflict in love - Jan 13, 2011
- Power without status glories in demeaning others - Sep 21, 2011
- Large-scale tragedies 'don't connect with people emotionally' - Sep 10, 2010
- Gibson rues another "bad hour" after Windies collapse - Apr 18, 2012
- I'm into androgyny: Evan Rachel Wood - Apr 19, 2011
- Unbridled power fuels overconfidence, bad decisions - Mar 02, 2012
- Controlling temptation more difficult than believed - Aug 04, 2009
- LEDs may help improve cognitive function after traumatic brain injury - Mar 18, 2011
- 'Genes key to self-control, sociability' - May 17, 2012
Tags: al capone, alpha status, author robert, dominant leader, dominant power, good guys, graduate school of business, group context, journal of personality, journal of personality and social psychology, kellogg school of management, moral standards, mother teresa, nice guys, psychology researchers, robert livingston, school of management, stanford graduate school, stanford graduate school of business, study author