US Supreme Court rejects bid to tax India’s UN missionJune 28th, 2011 - 10:20 pm ICT by IANS
Washington, June 28 (IANS) The US Supreme Court has rejected New York City’s bid to collect $42.5 million from India in unpaid property taxes for its mission to the United Nations as diplomatic missions are exempt from such taxes.
The court Monday upheld a federal appeals court ruling that rejected New York’s city contention, pointing to a 2009 State Department notice that said UN missions were exempt from local property taxes.
“While there is perhaps some unfairness to the city when the federal government retroactively declares property taxes imposed by the city against foreign countries to be null and void, this unfairness inheres in the federal government’s unquestioned supremacy in the management of foreign relations,” the judges wrote.
The appeals court ruling had overruled judgments the city had won against India and Mongolia in seeking to tax the parts of foreign diplomatic missions used to house employees and their families.
In India’s case, that meant the top 20 floors of its 26-floor building on East 43rd Street. Mongolia’s mission occupies five floors on East 77th Street, with two used for employee housing.
A federal trial judge had awarded New York $42.5 million in taxes, charges and interest against India and $4.4 million against Mongolia.
After the trial court ruling, the State Department issued its notice. The New York-based 2nd US Circuit Court of Appeals then reversed the judge’s decision, rejecting the city’s contention that the State Department lacked authority to pre-empt local tax laws.
New York sued India, Mongolia, Turkey and the Philippines to collect claimed taxes in 2003. Turkey and the Philippines settled with the city, agreeing to pay a total of $12 million.
The Supreme Court ruled in 2007 that the city’s suit could go forward, rejecting India’s contention that it was immune.
(Arun Kumar can be contacted at firstname.lastname@example.org)
- India wins property tax battle with New York City - Aug 18, 2010
- India, Mongolia win cases on tax-free diplomatic properties - Aug 18, 2010
- Court tells Wipro to deposit Rs.240 mn in tax case - Dec 29, 2010
- Wipro deposits Rs.240 mn in tax case on court order (Lead) - Dec 29, 2010
- Why is US paying to make Indian politicians better? - Dec 21, 2011
- US court asks India to pay tax for New York property - Mar 19, 2008
- Taxing fashion shows: High Court declines to interfere - May 16, 2012
- US wants HSBC to reveal American tax dodgers in India - Apr 08, 2011
- Relief for Gujarat construction company in tax case - Mar 07, 2011
- Government seeks review of Supreme Court's Vodafone verdict (Lead) - Feb 18, 2012
- US takes India to WTO over poultry import bar - May 12, 2012
- Making housing affordable: Realty industry needs budget boost (Comment) - Feb 26, 2012
- Government's plea for Vodafone verdict review dismissed (Lead) - Mar 20, 2012
- Indian American doctor charged with hiding India accounts - Sep 29, 2011
- Judge to make rulings in the Jerry Sandusky case - Feb 13, 2012
Tags: 5 million, 77th street, arun kumar, contention, court of appeals, diplomatic missions, federal appeals court, federal government, federal trial judge, foreign countries, foreign relations, judgments, mongolia, philippines, state department, supreme court, trial court, unfairness, united nations, unpaid property taxes