US may keep its hands off China-Pakistan n-deal (Lead)May 25th, 2010 - 5:21 pm ICT by IANS
By Arun Kumar
Washington, May 25 (IANS) Two noted American experts want Washington to block the China-Pakistan nuclear deal even as the US indicated it will not come in the way if it adhered to the Nuclear Suppliers Group (NSG) rules.
“I don’t know if this will come up during the secretary’s meetings in China this week,” State Department spokesman P.J. Crowley told reporters Monday when asked if Secretary of State Hillary Clinton would take it up in Beijing.
“We are talking to China more broadly about the implications of this deal. It has a lengthy history to it,” he said, when asked if the China-Pakistan deal would come up at the ongoing Strategic and Economic Dialogue with China in Beijing and the one with India here next week.
“But we will seek to make sure that should this deal go forward, it is in compliance with the rules of the NSG,” Crowley said.
Crowley’s comments came as Lisa Curtis and Nicholas Hamisevicz, South Asia experts at Heritage Foundation, a Washington think-tank, urged the Obama administration to block the China-Pakistan deal, saying India and Pakistan had vastly different proliferation records.
There are signs of the Obama administration softening its position towards Chinese-Pakistani nuclear cooperation, they said, noting that US officials have avoided pressing China against moving forward with a deal to supply two new nuclear reactors to Pakistan.
“The Obama administration’s policy contrasts with that of the previous Bush administration, which actively discouraged additional Chinese assistance to Pakistan’s nuclear programme,” said Curtis and Hamisevicz.
“Given the widespread proliferation that resulted from the Pakistan-based A.Q. Khan network - as well as continued concerns about the existence of terrorist networks in Pakistan that seek access to nuclear weapons technology - a nod from Washington to further Chinese-Pakistani nuclear cooperation is short-sighted,” they said.
The argument that the China-Pakistan nuclear reactor deal should be seen in the same light as the US-India civil nuclear deal “discounts the vastly different proliferation records of Pakistan and India, the different oversight requirements generally imposed by the US compared to China, and the prevalence of Pakistan-based terrorist groups seeking nuclear weapons technology”, they said.
An Obama administration decision to allow the China-Pakistan nuclear deal to advance unhindered would be a high-stakes diplomatic gamble, the two experts argued.
“Beijing would likely pocket US acquiescence while continuing only the most grudging cooperation on America’s highest international priorities.
“At the same time, Pakistan’s increased access to civilian nuclear technology without sufficient legal context and safeguards poses a potential proliferation threat and danger to nuclear safety and security on the Subcontinent,” Curtis and Hamisevicz said.
(Arun Kumar can be contacted at email@example.com)
- US may turn a blind eye to China-Pakistan n-deal - May 25, 2010
- US opposes China-Pakistan nuke deal - Jun 16, 2010
- US all but gives up on stalling Sino-Pak nuclear agreement - Jul 04, 2010
- India closely watching NSG meet on China-Pakistan n-deal - Jun 15, 2010
- 'Peaceful' nuclear deal with Pak in line with international obligations: China - Jun 17, 2010
- India pleased yet guarded on nuke group's stand - Jun 26, 2010
- Pressure China to reverse n-deal with Pakistan: US expert - Jul 20, 2010
- US says China can't do nuclear deal with Pak sans NSG approval - Jun 16, 2010
- US committed to India n-deal despite Japan disaster - Mar 19, 2011
- US, China on collision course over helping Pak build nuke reactors - Jun 21, 2010
- US questions China on reactor sales to Pakistan - Jun 29, 2010
- Why China struck n-deal with Pakistan 4 days after Indo-US deal (News Analysis) - Jun 29, 2010
- Worried US demands China nuclear pact details from Pak - Oct 22, 2010
- India taps NSG over China-Pakistan n-deal - Jun 20, 2010
- India examining China-Pakistan n-deal, leaves it to NSG - May 25, 2010
Tags: american experts, arun kumar, asia experts, bush administration, chinese assistance, crowley, economic dialogue, heritage foundation, hillary clinton, india and pakistan, lengthy history, nuclear cooperation, nuclear deal, nuclear reactors, nuclear suppliers group, nuclear weapons technology, proliferation, South Asia, state department spokesman, think tank