US can’t with Afghan war with Soviet-style ‘defend the cities’ strategy: Expert
October 29th, 2009 - 4:09 pm ICT by ANI
Toronto, Oct. 29 (ANI): The American approach to “defend the cities” in Afghanistan and let the Taliban control the rural areas appears to be more of a delaying-the-defeat tactic than a victory strategy, according to an expert. The “defend the cities” option is gaining favour in Washington as President Barack Obama nears a decision on whether to send tens of thousands of extra American soldiers to Afghanistan. Even before his decision, NATO and U.S. commander in Afghanistan, General Stanley McChrystal, had ordered a temporary pullback of troops from remote and vulnerable outposts, The Globe and the Mail reports.
“The Biden approach would effectively abandon large swaths of territory to the Taliban, sending a signal to the Afghan government and people that the United States isn’t serious about reconstruction,” said Professor Mark Sedra, a researcher for International Governance Innovation.
“Just defending the cities would be not quite as extreme but it would still abandon Afghanistan’s mostly rural population,” he added.”Defending the cities” was the strategy that failed the Soviets in 1980, an old US State Department review itself had found. A review of the Soviet effort to subjugate Afghanistan read: “The Soviets and their Kabul allies are able to exercise effective control over only a small fraction of Afghanistan. Except for sweep operations, they rarely venture away from their own bases, parts of the cities, and the major highways. At night, even these are not safe for them. “Most of the country’s rural areas remain beyond Soviet and regime control,” it concluded in 1985. (ANI)
- Obama in dilemma over sacking McChrystal, Afghan war effort - Jun 23, 2010
- US commander McChrystal derides Vice-President Biden, Holbrooke and envoy - Jun 22, 2010
- Obama fires top Afghanistan commander McChrystal (Second Lead) - Jun 24, 2010
- Ex-NATO commander McChrystal cleared of wrongdoing in Rolling Stone piece - Apr 19, 2011
- Obama Speaks: Gen Stanley McChrystal Resigns & Gen David Petraeus Steps In - Jun 24, 2010
- Afghan war is at a stalemate: General McChrystal - May 14, 2010
- Top US commander in Afghanistan resigns (Lead) - Jun 24, 2010
- President Of United States Fires Gen. Stanley McChrystal, Gives Power To Gen. David Petraeus - Jun 24, 2010
- 'Angry' Obama recalls Afghan commander to Washington - Jun 23, 2010
- McChrystal brings erring US Special Forces in Afghanistan under his direct control - Mar 16, 2010
- US Open to increase troops in Afghanistan: Pentagon - Sep 04, 2009
- Obama to grant request for more troops in Afghanistan: Report - Nov 10, 2009
- US official feels substantial progress has been made in Afghanistan - Oct 29, 2010
- Pentagon assessing Af-Pak strategy to decide future action: Mullen - Aug 05, 2009
- Afghanistan not in danger of falling to Taliban: Obama adviser - Oct 05, 2009
Tags: afghan government, afghan war, american approach, american soldiers, barack obama, biden, effective control, general stanley mcchrystal, international governance, kabul, mail, outposts, professor mark, pullback, rural areas, soviet style, soviets, strategy expert, sweep operations, us state department