US army officers call Brit troop withdrawal from Basra in 2007 “a defeat”
September 29th, 2010 - 5:56 pm ICT by ANIWashington, Sept 29 (ANI): Senior American army officers have claimed that Britain’s withdrawal of troops from Basra in Iraq in 2007 was a ‘defeat,’ which left the city ‘terrorised’ by militias.
General Jack Keane, who is a key adviser to the White House, has claimed that the UK had committed a “huge mistake” by pulling out its troops from Basra and leaving the inhabitants of the city to suffer at the hands of the insurgents.
“I think it was a huge mistake to pull out of Basra and to go out to the airfield and leave the people of Basra to be subjected to the Iranian surrogates who brutalised them, intimidated them, terrorised them,” the BBC quoted General Keane, as saying.
Another US officer, Colonel Peter Mansoor, who worked directly for the US commander in Iraq at that time, also described Britain’s withdrawal as “a defeat”.
“I don’t know that you could see the British withdrawal from Basra in 2007 in any light other than a defeat,” Col Mansoor, who was executive officer to General David Petraeus, said.
After the invasion in 2003, the city of Basra appeared to be less violent than Baghdad and central Iraq. However, just a year before the troops were withdrawn, rebellion spread to the south and attacks on British forces increased. By 2007, it worsened as the British troops were attacked almost regularly through different ways like roadside bombs and rockets that were fired at their bases, the report said.
The British commander in southern Iraq, General Jonathan Shaw who negotiated the withdrawal with the local Shia militia leader in Basra, said that his actions were constrained by political considerations in London.
“I think the biggest problem was the political problem. There was America surging. There was Britain reducing force levels. Our political leaderships were moving in different directions and that was extremely awkward,” he added. (ANI)
- Afghan withdrawal date 'emboldens' Taliban - Sep 04, 2010
- 23 protesters killed in Iraq's 'Day of Rage' - Feb 26, 2011
- Britain's Defence Ministry suppresses military defeat report on Afghanistan - Sep 06, 2009
- Singer James Blunt 'prevented World War III' - Nov 15, 2010
- 'US withdrawal closes important chapter in Iraq history' - Dec 16, 2011
- Manchesters security more fragile than Basra: British General - Feb 07, 2009
- Iraqi general claims UK troops allowed insurgents to rule Basra - Nov 22, 2008
- US general backs report saying Afghan withdrawal date 'emboldens' Taliban - Sep 04, 2010
- Iraqi private security firms operate "mafia" to raise their "outrageous prices": Wikileaks - Dec 22, 2010
- `We will leave Iraq a better place, says UK general - Mar 02, 2009
- UK hands over military command of Iraq to US - Mar 31, 2009
- Taliban impostor was "groomed by ISI to delay, counter check us": NATO official - Nov 26, 2010
- Taliban strike Kabul, other Afghan targets (Second Lead) - Apr 15, 2012
- British army cleared of torturing Iraqi to death - Aug 28, 2011
- Britain begins to pull out troops from Iraq - Mar 31, 2009
Tags: american army, army officers, basra, bombs and rockets, british commander, british troops, british withdrawal, central iraq, david petraeus, general david petraeus, jonathan shaw, leaderships, militia leader, militias, peter mansoor, political considerations, roadside bombs, southern iraq, surrogates, us commander