South Africa infuriated as Canada grants refuge to white man
September 3rd, 2009 - 2:15 pm ICT by IANSToronto, Sep 3 (IANS) The Canadian decision to grant refugee status to a white South African who alleged racial discrimination in his home country has assumed racial overtones, with South Africa criticising the decision.
Brandon Huntley, who came to Canada in 2006 and was granted refugee status last week, said he could not find a job in his native country because of his skin colour. He alleged that repeated attacks by robbers and muggers forced him to seek refuge in Canada.
In his application, Huntley said whites in South Africa are at the receiving end from black criminals, and the government was doing nothing to protect them.
In granting Huntley permanent stay in Canada, the immigration and tribunal judge said the man has “presented clear and convincing proof of the state’s inability or unwillingness to protect him. I find that the claimant was a victim because of his race (white South African) rather than a victim of criminality.”
But the ruling infuriated South Africa which called Huntley’s allegations “sensational and alarming”.
Reports here quoted South African immigration ministry spokesperson Ronnie Mamoepa as saying that Huntley’s allegations were “racially motivated and aimed at tarnishing the good name of black and white South Africans”.
The spokesperson said it would have been “courteous for the Canadian government to allow the South African government to respond to these claims”.
African National Congress (ANC) spokesperson Ishmael Mnisi was quoted as saying that “Canada’s reasoning for granting Huntley refugee status can only serve to perpetuate racism”.
The case assumes significance as the current Canadian immigration and refugee system is virtually broken, with more than 60,000 refugee cases pending before the immigration panel.
Each case takes years and costs Canadian taxpayers about $30,000.
Canadian taxpayers also pay millions of dollars each year for the upkeep of refugees and their families.
Critics blame the previous Liberal party governments for opening the floodgates for refugees, putting unbearable burden on the system and taxpayers.
- Canadian Govt to challenge racial refugee status decision - Sep 04, 2009
- Proteas refugee case causes backlash against 'racist' Canada - Sep 02, 2009
- Canada cracks down on human smugglers - Oct 22, 2010
- Canada hints LTTE behind human-smuggling ship - Aug 14, 2010
- Ujjal Dosanjh wants Canada to keep ex-KGB spy - Dec 21, 2009
- Canada's new law to shut doors on bogus refugees - Mar 29, 2010
- Sex-for-immigration lands Canadian judge in dock - Feb 23, 2010
- Canadian Muslim seeks millions for racial abuse - Dec 27, 2009
- Million foreign visitors in South Africa during World Cup period - Jul 05, 2010
- Elderly Caucasian passenger emerges from flight as young Asian man! - Nov 06, 2010
- Canada busts single biggest immigration racket - Jan 07, 2011
- Canada-bound female spouses from India need counselling - Jul 14, 2010
- Over 100 Tamil migrants heading to Canada arrested - Oct 30, 2010
- Hiding KGB agent faces deportation from Canada - Sep 24, 2009
- Canada to send back yet another Pakistani couple - Sep 08, 2009
Tags: african immigration, african national congress, alarming reports, canadian immigration, canadian taxpayers, clear and convincing proof, criminality, dollars each year, huntley, immigration and refugee, immigration panel, ishmael, muggers, racial discrimination, racial overtones, refugee cases, refugee status, skin colour, south african government, white south africans