Racial profiling to limit terriorism is fundamentally flawed: ExpertNovember 18th, 2010 - 5:58 pm ICT by ANI
Washington, Nov 18 (ANI): Racial profiling does no better in helping law enforcement officials in their task of catching terrorists than standard uniform random sampling techniques, says Professor William Press from the University of Texas at Austin.
Racial profiling rests on the idea that people from particular racial or ethnic groups are more likely to be involved in acts of terror than people from other groups.
The theory then suggests that law enforcement officers should spend a greater proportion of their time scrutinising people from the ‘high risk’ group.
One problem with this approach is that innocent people who also belong to the targeted group rapidly become offended, and some may even become radicalized as a result.
“Racial profiling is as indiscriminate as deciding that people named Patrick are more likely to drink and drive, and so everyone who is named Patrick should be stopped and breathalysed more frequently than people with other names,” said Press.
In a world threatened by terrorists from a small number of countries, it is tempting to think that racial profiling for security purposes, even if morally objectionable, might save lives.
“But uniform sampling, without the use of profiling, is surprisingly good. It is robust against false assumptions, it is deterrent, it is easy to implement, it is about as effective as any real-life system can be - and it is devoid of moral and political hazard,” said Press.
The author published his paper today in Significance, the magazine of the Royal Statistical Society and the American Statistical Association. (ANI)
- South Asian New Yorkers still confront profiling - Mar 23, 2012
- South Asians fear racial profiling over US court ruling - Jun 26, 2012
- Bangladesh to have sophisticated crime database - Dec 16, 2011
- Pakistan, US to expand counter-terror cooperation - Jul 06, 2011
- City Council of Dublin bans baggy pants - Sep 07, 2010
- Are terrorists using Facebook to exchange bomb recipes? - Dec 10, 2010
- Kashmiri religious group issues dress code for tourists - Jul 04, 2012
- Racial profiling undermining moral authority of democracy in UK: Jesse Jackson - Oct 18, 2010
- Want your kids to be CEOs? Then name them Peter and Deborah! - Apr 29, 2011
- Sikhs, Muslims seek end to racial profiling - Jun 18, 2010
- Apex court approves common curriculum for Tamil Nadu schools (lead) - Aug 09, 2011
- South Asians seek rejection of tough US immigration law - Apr 26, 2012
- Rape-accused guru Nityananada may lose his Bangalore ashram - Jun 09, 2012
- China to make visits to elderly parents compulsory - Jan 07, 2011
- Pak agencies still clueless about escaped high-profile Jundullah terrorists 4 months on - Oct 20, 2010
Tags: acts, american statistical association, false assumptions, high risk group, law enforcement officers, law enforcement officials, number of countries, problem with this approach, professor william, proportion, racial profiling, random sampling techniques, royal statistical society, security purposes, targeted group, terrorists, texas at austin, uniform sampling, university of texas, university of texas at austin