Obama’s speech not a game changer: US expertsJune 5th, 2009 - 10:50 am ICT by IANS
Washington, June 5 (IANS) The feel-good impact of President Barack Obama’s Cairo speech “is unlikely to last long or change opinions about America among those who object to US policies in the Middle East and South Asia”, according to two US experts.
“His pledge to fight against negative stereotypes of Islam was welcomed by Muslim observers,” noted Lisa Curtis, Senior Research Fellow for South Asia and James Phillips, Senior Research Fellow for Middle Eastern Affairs at The Heritage Foundation, a conservative Washington think tank.
But “by avoiding using the word “Islamist,” he is downplaying the ideological underpinnings for terrorism.”
“Obama is right that we should not equate terrorism with the religion of Islam, but we also need to be ready to engage in the battle of ideas and be clear when political Islam contradicts the ideals of individual freedom and religious liberty,” they said.
The two experts, however, agreed that Al Qaeda failed in its attempt to upstage the Obama speech.
Releasing two successive tapes this week, one on Tuesday by al-Zawahiri and one on Wednesday purportedly recorded by Osama bin Laden, Al Qaeda sought to portray Obama as an enemy of the Muslim world who was sowing hatred among the Muslim community, particularly with regard to US policies toward Pakistan, Curtis and Phillips said.
The videos demonstrate that Al Qaeda is worried about Obama’s ability to appeal to the Muslim community and is desperately searching for ways to blunt his ability to do so, they said.
In the two experts’ view, Al Qaeda is focusing its efforts on Pakistan, where US policies are often blamed for the rash of suicide bombings in the country over the last two years.
But “Al Qaeda may have erred by mentioning the situation in the Swat Valley, however, since the Pakistani public has recently galvanised behind the Pakistan military operations to oust the Taliban from the region,” they said.
“Pakistanis are increasingly viewing the Taliban as malevolent actors seeking to undermine the Pakistani state and its democratic institutions.”
- Zawahiri praises Osama on new video - Jun 09, 2011
- Zawahiri praises Osama on new video (Lead) - Jun 09, 2011
- Al-Qaeda says it is holding US hostage (Lead) - Dec 02, 2011
- Al-Qaeda says it is holding US hostage (Second Lead, Changing dateline) - Dec 02, 2011
- Al-Zawahiri appointed new Al Qaeda leader (Second Lead) - Jun 16, 2011
- Al Qaeda deputy demands Arab armies' intervention in Libya to oust Gaddafi - Apr 15, 2011
- US doubts Al Qaeda leader Zawahiri has fled Pakistan - Sep 15, 2011
- Al-Zawahiri appointed new Al Qaeda leader (Lead, Changing dateline) - Jun 16, 2011
- Al-qaeda 'thrives' in countries having weak governance: FBI - Apr 16, 2011
- Al Qaeda operations chief killed in Pakistan - Sep 16, 2011
- Al Qaeda chief wants '9/11' of his own - Sep 10, 2011
- Despite split reports, al-Zawahiri could be new Al Qaeda boss - May 07, 2011
- Al-Qaeda holding US aid worker hostage in Pakistan - Dec 02, 2011
- Ayman al-Zawahiri, America's new most wanted - May 05, 2011
- Experts urge US not to make 'hasty' retreat from Afghanistan - Jan 29, 2011
Tags: al zawahiri, barack obama, conservative washington, heritage foundation, individual freedom, james phillips, middle eastern affairs, muslim community, muslim world, negative stereotypes, obama speech, pakistanis, political islam, religion of islam, religious liberty, research fellow, South Asia, suicide bombings, swat valley, using the word