Obama speech stirs controversy at home
June 4th, 2009 - 11:14 pm ICT by IANS ( Leave a comment )
By Arun Kumar
Washington, June 4 (IANS) President Barack Obama’s Thursday speech to the Muslim world has stirred controversy at home with some calling it “a continuation of his detente” and others finding fault with his “studious avoidance” of the word “terrorism”.
The New York Times said Obama “delivered a sweeping message that was forceful and, at times, scolding”. And tweeting from Cairo, Washington Post’s staff writer Howard Schneider wrote: “Halftime analysis from the crowd: let’s see how he implements it.”
Speaking to Egyptians, the Times said “all the polish and all the excitement will fade shortly after Air Force One lifts off, most people here say, if nothing changes in the Palestinian-Israeli conflict.”
The Wall Street Journal said Obama was “shrewd” to include a passage on women’s rights, “noteworthy coming from the father of two girls”.
CNN’s Christiane Amanpour called the speech “a continuation of President Obama’s detente” with the Muslim world.
But Obama’s citing of his own background invited mockery from some quarters with the Politico’s Mike Allen calling the comments “by far the most extensive he has made about his Muslim roots.”
Michael Rubin of conservative weblog The Corner also found fault with Obama’s studious avoidance of the word “terrorism”.
Questioning Obama’s “balanced tone” on the the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, the Republican Jewish Coalition’s Matthew Brooks said: “American policy should not be balanced - it should side with those who fight terror, not those who either engage in it or are too weak to prevent it.”
The Times’ Helene Cooper said Muslims will judge Obama by actions more than words. It is too soon to tell whether Obama’s speech “will be the balm to America’s broken relationship with Islam that White House officials hope,” she said.
But one thing is already clear, Cooper said, while “Obama’s strong words may resonate today, on the Arab street and in the madrassas and the tea shops and dining tables where the world’s 1.5 billion Muslims congregate, the future actions of Obama will be far more important.”
- Obama's stature among Muslims slips over Israeli-Palestinian standoff - Jun 05, 2010
- Obama speech gets mixed early reaction at home - Jun 04, 2009
- Obama less favorably viewed among Muslims: Survey - Jun 18, 2010
- Netanyahu, Mubarak discuss proximity talks in Egypt - May 03, 2010
- US-brokered Mideast peace summit begins - Sep 02, 2010
- Netanyahu praises Obama's push for Mid-East peace talks - Sep 24, 2009
- More Israelis, Palestinians willing to compromise: Poll - Dec 29, 2011
- US backing Mubarak's "consigliere" Suleiman in Egypt transition moves - Feb 08, 2011
- Al-Jazeera exposed 'Palestine Papers' has made Israel-Palestine peace pact harder: US - Jan 25, 2011
- India reiterates 'unequivocal support' for Palestinian state - Sep 23, 2011
- Obama calls Abbas, favours direct Palestine-Israel talks - Jul 10, 2010
- No alternative to peace talks: Abbas (Lead, Changing dateline) - Sep 16, 2010
- Israel should meet its obligations to revive peace: Abbas - Dec 31, 2011
- Clinton says resolution condemning Israeli settlement will not bring peace - Jan 21, 2011
- Hezbollah says Obama gave a sermon - Jun 05, 2009
Tags: air force one, arab street, arun kumar, barack obama, broken relationship, christiane amanpour, cnn, halftime analysis, helene cooper, howard schneider, israeli palestinian conflict, jewish coalition, madrassas, matthew brooks, michael rubin, muslim world, palestinian israeli conflict, tea shops, wall street journal, washington post