More screening could mean less secure airports
February 1st, 2012 - 3:25 pm ICT by IANS ( Leave a comment )Washington, Feb 1 (IANS) Intensive screening makes airport security unsafe by targeting low risk passengers rather than those who pose real threats, and this is particularly true after 9/11, a new study says.
Illinois University computer science and mathematics professor Sheldon H. Jacobson, along with Adrian J. Lee at the Central Illinois Technology, explored the possibility of matching passenger risk with security assets.
Jacobson’s previous work indicates that resources could be more effectively invested if the lowest-risk segments, frequent travellers, for instance, could pass through security with less scrutiny since they are “known” to the system, the journal Transportation Science reports.
In the new study, Jacobson and Lee developed three algorithms dealing with risk uncertainty in the passenger population, according to an Illinois statement.
They found that risk-based screening, such as the Transportation Security Administration’s new pre-check programme, increases the overall expected security.
“A natural tendency, when limited information is available about from where the next threat will come, is to overestimate the overall risk in the system,” Jacobson said.
“This actually makes the system less secure by over-allocating security resources to those in the system that are low on the risk scale relative to others in the system,” Jacobson added, according to an Illinois statement.
Consequently, a larger proportion of high-risk passengers are designated for too little screening while a larger proportion of low-risk passengers are subjected to too much screening.
“One hundred percent checked baggage screening and full-body scanning of all passengers is the antithesis of a risk-based system,” Jacobson said.
- US Transportation Security Administration to start 'Trusted Traveler Program' - Oct 05, 2011
- Reverse gear: obesity fuelling increased auto usage - May 12, 2011
- 'Now 'body scanners' could be deployed at US train stations, subways, other mass transits' - Nov 26, 2010
- Airlines to start 'Trusted traveler program' - Oct 04, 2011
- Now thermoses, coffee cups added to terror weapons list - Dec 25, 2010
- Now drink containers under scanner at North American airports (Lead) - Dec 25, 2010
- Full-body scanner row: US denies checking all travellers - Nov 23, 2010
- Healthy lifestyle has biggest impact on cardiovascular health - Nov 16, 2010
- US expert hits back at claims of 'safe' full-body airport scanners - Nov 12, 2010
- Security checks at US airports to get more 'touchy' - Oct 29, 2010
- American Muslim groups protest use of unIslamic full body scanners at airports - Mar 16, 2010
- US seeking privacy-security balance over airport security: Robert Gibbs - Nov 23, 2010
- California Man John Tyner Refuses Body Scan In San Diego Airport - Nov 16, 2010
- US, India natural allies against terror financing: US official - Jul 28, 2011
- Muslim-American body issues fatwa against airport body scanners - Feb 12, 2010
Tags: airport security, antithesis, baggage screening, central illinois, frequent travellers, high risk, illinois statement, illinois technology, illinois university, intensive screening, j lee, jacobson, mathematics professor, natural tendency, professor sheldon, science reports, security resources, transportation science, transportation security administration, university computer science