Mixed reaction to Kiwi MP’s scuffle with Chinese team
June 22nd, 2010 - 2:34 pm ICT by ANI
Wellington, June 22 (ANI): International relations experts have also expressed mixed views over Member of Parliament Russel Norman’s embarrassing scuffle with a visiting Chinese delegation.
According to the New Zealand Herald, some of its readers believe that it was an “attention-seeking stunt”.
Others said that an apology from the Prime Minister without an inquiry “sends the wrong signal”, while others say it was necessary to save face after the Green Party co-leader’s “intimidating” protest for Tibetans.
“I view what’s his name Norman as a loony, left wing, sort of clichéd political pantomime actor in a suit … In this instance, however, I think the embarrassment is with the Government who placed the rights and freedoms enjoyed by all New Zealand behind the interests to kissing up to the Chinese,” said Odette, one of the readers.
Others shared similar sentiments in defence of New Zealand’s freedom of speech.
“It’s not complicated - the New Zealand Government is simply scared of a bigger, tougher Government,” said Charles, another reader.
Others, however, criticised Dr Norman for his rudeness.
“No, John Key should not have to apologise to the Chinese delegation, but Russel Norman should - on his hands and knees,” said Zuxian.
“Of course Key was right to apologise … China is the only reason why New Zealand, and Australia, are not going through the current economic and social travails of Greece and Spain,” said Wayne Lo, from Auckland’s Mt Albert.
“The Chinese have a tradition of resisting public pressure, not to mention public humiliation,” said Auckland University’s Dr Jian Yang, an expert in China’s foreign relations.
The incident might not only dissuade Chinese leaders from visiting in the future, but it could also be counterproductive to promoting Tibetan interests, Dr Yang said. (ANI)
- Kiwi MP's pro-China blog appalls Tibet's friends - Jul 03, 2010
- Australian PM denied chance to address New Zealand parliament - Feb 15, 2011
- 14 Tibetans detained for protesting against India-China talks - Mar 01, 2012
- Oz PM will not be allowed to address Kiwi Parliament - Feb 14, 2011
- US to discuss Tibet situation with China - Feb 11, 2012
- China chasing embezzled money in New Zealand - May 24, 2010
- Ahead of Hu's visit, India, China hold talks (Lead) - Mar 01, 2012
- Tibetans protest as India, China hold talks - Mar 01, 2012
- 'Shun Tibetan New Year celebrations' - Feb 03, 2012
- Fast, prayers mark Tibetan New Year festival (Lead) - Feb 22, 2012
- Tibet situation grim, needs global intervention, say exiles - Feb 24, 2012
- European Parliament asks Nepal to let Tibetan refugees vote - Apr 09, 2011
- Unrest in Tibet: Exiles seeks global intervention - Feb 06, 2012
- Watching porn 'can help cure premature ejaculation' - Nov 09, 2010
- India, China hold maiden border mechanism talks - Mar 06, 2012
Tags: auckland university, chinese delegation, chinese leaders, chinese team, clich, course key, dr norman, dr yang, freedom of speech, hands and knees, jian yang, john key, member of parliament, mt albert, new zealand government, new zealand herald, party co, public humiliation, rudeness, tibetans