Experts say elitist Gandhi pen risks possibility of a backlash
October 1st, 2009 - 5:16 pm ICT by ANILondon, Oct.1 (ANI): Well known Swiss pen manufacturer Montblanc’s decision to unveil a gold and silver fountain pen to commemorate Mahatma Gandhi, the spearhead of India’s independence movement in the early part of the 20th century, has provoked criticism and risks the possibility of a backlash.
Suhel Seth, a brand expert with Counselage, a Delhi marketing firm, said using the image of Gandhi “risked a backlash”.
“Look at the illogical marketing. Montblanc is an elite product, a luxury product. Gandhi stood for everything that was non-elitist. Here is a pen that uses the idiom of a man who believed in third-class travel to promote a first-world product to luxurious desktops,” the Financial Times quoted Seth, as saying.
“I think it’s such a misread of the Indian psyche. When you tinker around with that symbol of credibility, respect and honour, you risk a backlash that no brand needs or deserves,” he added.
Amit Modi, secretary of the 102-year-old Sabarmati Ashram that Gandhi founded to promote his ideas of radical egalitarianism and simple living, said: “If he had seen this, he would have thrown it away.”
“I cannot imagine why anybody has done this. We cannot recognise this,” The Telegraph quoted him as saying further.
Tushar Gandhi, the Mahatma’s great-grandson, who received 91,500 pounds as payment from Montblanc to build a shelter for rescued child labourers, told the Financial Times that: “I know there is a contradiction between the man they are commemorating and the product they are commemorating him with, but you can’t expect a company like Montblanc to come out with a cheap thing.”
The limited-edition pen, priced at 14,400 pounds, has an 18-carat solid gold, rhodium-plated nib, and “a saffron-coloured mandarin garnet” on the clip.
The pen is also engraved with Gandhi’s image, despite the fact that Indian companies generally avoid using it, given his exalted status. (ANI)
- `Gandhi would have wanted to share Montblanc pen with entire country'says expert - Oct 03, 2009
- Hindus want Montblanc to donate some Gandhi pen profits to Gandhi charities - Sep 30, 2009
- Will not use the Mahatma's picture commercially: Montblanc - May 03, 2010
- Swiss pen depicting Lord Shiva launched in India (With Image) - Feb 24, 2010
- 'Global brands can generate jobs in India' (With Image) - May 21, 2012
- Strokes of ancient history - on limited edition pens (With Images) - Aug 31, 2010
- Lawsuit challenges Mont Blanc for using Gandhi as poster boy - Dec 01, 2009
- Government's stand sought on Mont Blanc using Gandhi's image - Dec 07, 2009
- Suhel Seth denies 'casting couch' comment - May 20, 2012
- Gold pen studded with 850 diamonds put on display - Nov 11, 2010
- Rhodium helpful in checking food adulteration - Jul 22, 2011
- Netizens slam Sushma's Rajghat jig (Lead) - Jun 09, 2011
- Netizens slam Sushma's Rajghat jig - Jun 08, 2011
- Aguilera pays tribute to John Lennon - Sep 14, 2010
- Anil, Sonam team for television commercial (With Images) - Sep 23, 2009
Tags: backlash, brand expert, child labourers, class travel, elite product, elitist, exalted status, financial times, fountain pen, gold and silver, independence movement, luxury product, mahatma gandhi, marketing firm, pen manufacturer, radical egalitarianism, sabarmati ashram, solid gold, spearhead, suhel seth