Dharun Ravi seeks webcam spy case dismissalMay 2nd, 2012 - 12:06 pm ICT by IANS
New York, May 2 (IANS) Lawyers for an Indian American student found guilty of bias crimes for spying with a webcam on his roommate having an intimate encounter with another man have sought dismissal of his conviction and a new trial.
In 32-page motion filed Tuesday before a New Jersey state Superior Court, lawyers for Dharun Ravi, 20, a former Rutgers state university student, asked that the invasion of privacy counts should be overturned.
Among the reasons were that the state failed to show Ravi knew he wasn’t permitted to view his webcam when he did - a key element of the count, attorneys Steven Altman and Philip Nettl argued.
“On the contrary, all reasonable inferences suggest that he thought he was entitled to view his own room,” the lawyers wrote.
They also said prosecutors had not proven Ravi attempted to view his own webcam on Sep 21.
Altman and Nettl challenged the bias intimidation convictions - where the jury concluded in some cases that Ravi had purposely and knowingly intimidated his roommate Tyler Clementi, while in others that Clementi believed he was being targeted because he was gay.
Specifically, the attorneys said there was no evidence shown that Ravi’s actions were intended to threaten Clementi. They also said Ravi was not biased toward Clementi because of his sexual orientation and that Clementi had not feared Ravi.
If the request is denied and Ravi is sentenced to prison, his lawyers are seeking bail for Ravi as he appeals the verdict.
Ravi is expected to be sentenced May 21 after being found guilty of each of the 15 counts levelled against him, including invasion of privacy and bias intimidation - a hate crime.
He faces up to 10 years in prison and could also be deported to his native India based on the conviction.
- Jury deliberates in Indian student spying case in US - Mar 15, 2012
- Dharun Ravi found guilty in webcam spying case - Mar 16, 2012
- Found guilty, Indian American student faces deportation - Mar 17, 2012
- 30-day jail for Indian student Dharun Ravi; no deportation (Lead) - May 22, 2012
- Dharun Ravi sent messages to roommate on night of suicide - Mar 08, 2012
- Dharun Ravi is just a kid: Defence lawyer - Mar 14, 2012
- Indicted Indian-American student's act a 'stupid teenage prank' - Feb 25, 2012
- Before going to jail, Dharun Ravi apologises - May 30, 2012
- Dharun Ravi doesn't testify in US student spying case - Mar 13, 2012
- Dharun Ravi wasn't anti-gay, pals say - Mar 10, 2012
- Lawyer wants charges dropped against Indian-American student - Aug 12, 2011
- Indian-origin US student indicted for Jersey roommate's suicide - Apr 21, 2011
- Dharun Ravi's lawyers want 9 charges dropped - Mar 09, 2012
- Indian American student was not homophobic: Defence - Mar 01, 2012
- Indian American prefers trial in webcam spy case - Oct 21, 2011
Tags: altman, bias crimes, conviction, court lawyers, hate crime, inferences, intimate encounter, intimidation, invasion of privacy, native india, nettl, page motion, privacy counts, prosecutors, ravi, roommate, rutgers state university, sexual orientation, spy case, state superior court