Catholic media criticizes “Eat Pray Love” movie & appears to belittle Hinduism
August 18th, 2010 - 3:07 pm ICT by ANINevada (US), Aug 18 (ANI): Catholic media has been largely critical of Oscar winner Julia Roberts starrer “Eat Pray Love” movie and in the process appeared to belittle Hinduism concepts and symbols.
Noted Hindu statesman Rajan Zed, in a statement in Nevada (USA) today, said that we were all looking for the truth. Instead of condescending dismissal and highlighting flaws of others, we should learn from each other through dialogue in our shared quest for truth, and thus come nearer to the truth.
“America” Magazine from New York, which calls itself “The National Catholic Weekly”, wrote about “Eat Pray Love” movie: “It is potentially dangerous. It will exploit the common desire among women for the diligent joy which Gilbert so beautifully names with products that falsely promise such contentment”.
Catholic News Service headquartered in Washington DC, apparently talking about Rome portion of the movie, said: “Though she seemingly hits every restaurant in town, she gives the churches a pass, the implication being that she knows better than to look to Catholicism for insight”. Its description of the India ashram (hermitage), which Liz Gilbert (played by Julia Roberts) visits, includes, “The unhealthy atmosphere of semi-idolatrous worship…”. It blames Emmy nominated director Ryan Murphy’s movie for “…negating, or at least ignoring, the spiritual resources of Christianity…”. It gives the movie a classification of “L”, which includes “films whose problematic content many adults would find troubling”.
“National Catholic Register” from North Haven (Connecticut) argues: “Her strange incuriosity regarding Italy’s spiritual heritage is all the odder in light of her spiritual aspirations during her time in India”. It adds: “Even Eastern religion is all very well up to a point…”
Rajan Zed, who is President of Universal Society of Hinduism, further said that more broader and inclusive understanding of the religion was needed in the world today. Despite our seriously different traditions, we should learn to live together in mutual trust and peace, Zed added.
Roberts, who grew up with a Catholic mother and Baptist father, announced sometime back that she was a practicing Hindu.
Shot is USA, Italy, India, and Indonesia, and released in USA and Canada on August 13, “Eat Pray Love” will reportedly be released in India on August 27. (ANI)
- Hindus feel US Conference of Catholic Bishops ridicules Hinduism in "Eat Pray Love" review - Aug 18, 2010
- Julia Roberts is among top "Religion Stories" of 2010 - Jan 01, 2011
- Picture of guru "Neem Karoli Baba" attracted Julia Roberts to Hinduism - Aug 10, 2010
- 'Eat Pray Love' Julia Roberts Movie Worries Hindus - Mar 22, 2010
- Hindus concerned about Julia Roberts' "Eat, Pray, Love" - Mar 21, 2010
- Hindu Organizations Anxious Over The Portrayal Of Hinduism in Julia Roberts' 'Eat, Pray, Love' - Mar 22, 2010
- Hindus warmly welcome Julia Roberts to Hinduism - Aug 05, 2010
- Catholic Church Leaders Criticize Julia Roberts' Eat Pray Love - Aug 19, 2010
- Opting Hinduism not religious gimmick: Julia Roberts - Nov 14, 2010
- Catholic nuns & Hindu statesman Zed pray together in USA for "peace and love" - Feb 14, 2011
- After completing India shooting, Julia Roberts will head to Indonesia - Sep 28, 2009
- Hindus, who protested "Love Guru", congratulate Mike Myers on marriage - Mar 07, 2011
- Julia Roberts says essence of Christmas & Diwali is the same - Nov 03, 2010
- Julia Roberts movie 'Eat, Pray, Love' draws the ire of Hindus - Mar 22, 2010
- Devotees denied access to Temple used for shooting Julia Roberts' film - Sep 21, 2009
Tags: america magazine, ashram, catholic media, catholic news service, eastern religion, hindu statesman, hinduism, julia roberts, national catholic register, nevada usa, north haven connecticut, oscar winner, rajan zed, ryan murphy, spiritual aspirations, spiritual heritage, spiritual resources, time in india, universal society, usa today