Supreme Court reserves verdict on right to education (Lead)August 3rd, 2011 - 11:01 pm ICT by IANS
New Delhi, Aug 3 (IANS) The Supreme Court Wednesday reserved its verdict on a batch of petitions by private schools challenging the right to education law that mandates them to earmark 25 percent seats for poor students.
The apex court bench of Chief Justice S.H. Kapadia, Justice K.S. Panicker Radhakrishnan and Justice Swatanter Kumar reserved the verdict after the conclusion of the hearing in which un-aided private schools contended that reservation of 25 percent seats for poor children violated the educational institutions’ right to operate without state interference.
During the hearing, spread over many weeks, the court told the petitioners that the provision for earmarking 25 percent seats for poor children should not be viewed as some kind of reservation but as an attempt to impart education to all.
The private schools contended that compulsory enrolment of 25 percent poor students would cripple them financially.
The central government countered saying that private schools would be reimbursed money they would spend on the poor students.
The apex court said that for such a public-private partnership (PPP) to succeed there had to be a viable formula.
The court also chided the government for allocating less money for the education sector as compared to other countries.
In one of the hearings, Chief Justice Kapadia said: “You (government) are spending so much. You must spend for strengthening these schools.”
He went on to say that in South Africa they spend 7 percent of the GDP on education, yet they were facing problems because of the high costs of education and they were opting for the PPP route.
The court had also expressed its reservation on the provision of the law that eliminates examination for students up to Class 8.
Chief Justice Kapadia said that one area that was bothering the court was the elimination of examination for students up to Class 8. There should be some system of assessment before a student was promoted to the next class.
- Poor school students' quota: Apex court verdict Thursday - Apr 11, 2012
- Charity can't fund education-for-all: Apex court - Jul 20, 2011
- SC declines review of right to education verdict (Lead) - Sep 19, 2012
- SC upholds seats for poor under Right to Education (Second Lead) - Apr 12, 2012
- Government welcomes education act verdict, schools not too happy - Apr 12, 2012
- Seats for weaker sections under Right to Education valid: SC (Lead) - Apr 12, 2012
- 25 percent seats for poor under education act upheld (Second Lead) - Apr 12, 2012
- Compulsory education gives poor right to dignity: Court - Feb 17, 2011
- Sibal welcomes apex court decision on RTE - Apr 12, 2012
- Private schools are money spinning ventures: Supreme Court - Feb 24, 2011
- Right to education law, spectrum scam top apex court's agenda - Mar 13, 2011
- Can't touch seats reserved for OBC students: Apex court (Lead) - Aug 03, 2011
- 'Not sure about filing for review on RTE decision' - Apr 13, 2012
- Apex court warns private medical colleges against lapses - Jun 30, 2011
- Government questioned on school's refusal to admit poor - Feb 01, 2011
Tags: apex, apex court, central government, chief justice, class 8, court bench, court reserves, education law, education sector, educational institutions, kapadia, New Delhi, panicker, petitioners, petitions, poor students, private schools, public private partnership, radhakrishnan, state interference