Stop discrimination against beggars from other states: court
October 29th, 2009 - 10:15 pm ICT by IANS ( Leave a comment )New Delhi, Oct 29 (IANS) The Delhi High Court Thursday objected to the discrimination against beggars from other states and said it should be stopped.
Hearing a a public interest petition filed by social activist Harsh Mander, a division bench comprising Chief Justice Ajit Prakash Shah and Justice S.Muralidhar said: “The beggars are facing discrimination like what other people are facing in Maharashtra.”
“We should stop discriminating against beggars of other states and should see how we can improve their condition,” the bench said, asking the additional solicitor general to inform the court, by Nov 9, of what action the government is proposing to curb begging.
The court also asked the government to tell it what it was doing to educate the children of beggars living in shelter homes in the capital.
“If a person is destitute and begs for living, such a person cannot be treated as a criminal. He cannot be arrested or sentenced,” said Mander, who contended poverty can never be a crime and referred to the plight of a destitute who was jailed and sentenced for begging.
He also challenged the constitutional validity of the Bombay Prevention of Begging Act.
Mander’s counsel informed the court about the US method of tackling the menace, and noted that in that country the beggars are constitutionally protected and provided all basic facilities needed to live.
Citing Delhi’s example where beggars were allegedly living in the worst possible conditions, counsel said the beggars’ homes were in a bad shape and the government was paying only Rs.75 a day for their food and clothing, which is not sufficient.
“Moreover, the inhuman conditions in the homes forces beggars not to stay there,” the counsel added.
- Court satisfied with government's efforts to curb begging - Sep 17, 2009
- Government ready to change begging law, court told - Nov 09, 2009
- Beggars off Delhi roads before Games, court assured - Mar 14, 2010
- Court orders two special shelters for poor, pregnant women - Jan 12, 2011
- Is begging a crime? Court wants government's reply - Jul 29, 2009
- Supreme Court releases jailed Kerala CPI-M leader - Nov 15, 2011
- Bihar asked to set up more shelters for homeless people - Jun 17, 2011
- Sanskriti School pulled up for bias - Dec 16, 2009
- Supreme Court bench recuses itself from plea against OBC quota (Lead) - Jul 27, 2011
- Provide warm clothes, good food in juvenile homes: court - Dec 04, 2009
- Deport Pakistanis who have completed jail terms: Apex court (Lead) - Jan 24, 2012
- Settle beggars in villages: Gujarat High Court - Sep 23, 2010
- Beggars play hide and seek with Delhi authorities - Jul 31, 2010
- Guidelines for crime reporting to be formulated - Dec 17, 2009
- Larger apex court bench to decide Pakistani accused's plea (Lead) - Jan 12, 2012
Tags: ajit, bad shape, beggars, bombay, chief justice, constitutional validity, delhi high court, discrimination, division bench, harsh mander, inhuman conditions, New Delhi, plight, poverty, prakash shah, prevention, public interest petition, solicitor, states court