Some lawyers think they are above law: Supreme CourtMay 18th, 2009 - 7:00 pm ICT by IANS
New Delhi, May 18 (IANS) The Supreme Court Monday severely censured some lawyers for their attitude and said they consider themselves “above law” and it would not allow their “hooliganism”.
A vacation bench of Justice Markandey Katju and Justice Deepak Verma made the remarks against the lawyers while hearing a lawsuit by an Allahabad-based doctor, facing charges of murdering a patient who died in his hospital after receiving treatment for two months following a road accident.
The victim, Laxmi Kant Mishra, was a lawyer by profession. After his death local lawyers allegedly got a murder case registered with police against A.K. Bansal, the owner of the Jeevan Jyoti Nursing Hospital.
Bansal came to the apex court seeking protection against his impending arrest.
“Lawyers consider themselves above the law. They are increasingly getting out of control,” remarked Justice Katju, while hearing the lawsuit.
“Let them come to me. I will not allow their hooliganism,” he remarked.
Senior counsel Mukul Rohtagi, appearing for Bansal, narrated the tale of harassment of his client at the hand of lawyers in Allahabad.
Rohtagi told the court that Mishra had been brought to Bansal’s nursing home in a comatose state after a road accident in February and received treatment at the hospital for two months.
He, however, could not be saved and died April 26 following which over 200 advocates descended upon the hospital and vandalised it, Rohtagi said, adding that they also abused and manhandled doctors and hospital staffers.
Rohtagi said the group of lawyers, using their influence over police, even got a murder case registered against the doctor and began pressurising police to arrest him.
The lawyers even struck work in Allahabad courts May 1 and May 4 and held demonstrations in front of the nursing home demanding arrest of Bansal despite the fact that Mishra’s post-mortem had revealed that he had died of “septicemia and cardio-respiratory” failure, said Rohtagi.
As police refused to readily oblige the lawyers, they moved the Allahabad High Court with the sole prayer to direct police to arrest Bansal, said Rohtagi, adding that they sought the doctor’s arrest even without making him a party to the lawsuit.
Rohtagi also told the apex court that the lawyers did not even allow Bansal to be represented by any lawyer in the high court and thrashed fellow advocate J.S. Sengar, who appeared for Bansal in the high court May 12.
While seeking Bansal’s protection against arrest, Rohtagi also pleaded to the court to shift his trial to Delhi from Allahabad.
Acceding to the plea, the bench ordered the Allahabad police not to arrest Bansal till the disposal of his lawsuit at the apex court.
It also stayed proceeding against Bansal in the Allahabad High Court and issued notices to the victim’s brother S.N. Mishra, who, supported by local lawyers, had moved the high court for the doctor’s arrest.
- Allahabad High Court to file petition against apex court - Dec 03, 2010
- Supreme Court refuses to strike off 'something is rotten' remark - Dec 10, 2010
- Katju to head Press Council - Oct 05, 2011
- Pappu Yadav's bail plea rejected by apex court - Oct 07, 2010
- Supreme Court orders Allahabad HC to do some 'house cleaning' - Nov 26, 2010
- Aruna Shanbaug will live: Supreme Court (Roundup) - Mar 07, 2011
- Apex court to hear Allahabad High Court's plea Friday - Dec 09, 2010
- SC notice to CBI on Nupur Talwar's bail plea (Lead) - Jul 16, 2012
- Rajasekhara Reddy's widow withdraws plea from apex court - Jan 17, 2012
- Aruna Shanbaug to live: Supreme Court (Second Lead) - Mar 07, 2011
- Khalil Chisti's release to take a few days - Apr 09, 2012
- Lucknow jail death: Apex court favours independent probe (Lead) - Jul 08, 2011
- Mamata's fight against 'corruption in judiciary' (West Bengal Newsletter) - Aug 18, 2012
- Lahore doctors urged to end strike - Jul 08, 2012
- Apex court refuses to expunge 'rotten' remark - Dec 10, 2010