Sikhs called Bengalis ‘a trivial matter’: Malaysian Indian leaderApril 15th, 2008 - 4:12 pm ICT by admin
Kuala Lumpur, April 15 (IANS) A senior Malaysian Indian leader has urged the country’s Sikh community not to get annoyed at being called Bengalis, calling it “a trivial matter”. Opposition lawmaker Karpal Singh, who has roots in Punjab, has sought to play down Sunday’s gaffe by Perak state’s Mentri Besar (chief executive) Mohammad Nizar Jamaluddin, who he said, had referred to Sikhs as Bengalis “in ignorance”.
Urging the Sikh community “not to get upset”, Karpal Singh said although Sikhs and Bengalis were different, it was a very “trivial” matter.
“In Malaysia, both are commonly referred to as the same, so there is no need to be offended. After all, a rose would smell as sweet by any other name,” he said after attending Baisakhi prayers at a gurudwara Monday.
Some Sikhs in the audience walked out after Jamaluddin greeted the Tamils on the New Year and then the Sikhs, calling them Bengalis, a common misnomer in Malaysia.
Karpal Singh, who heads the opposition Democratic Action party (DAP), was elected to parliament in last month’s general elections where he sits alongside his son, Govind Singh Deo.
While he has sought to take a lenient view, some in the Sikh community of an estimated 100,000 do not agree.
Khalsa Dharmic Jatha Gurudwara vice-president Baljit Singh said: “That very utterance has made the Sikhs a laughing stock of other communities. How can we expect society to know the difference between the two communities when the leaders themselves cannot?” he said, adding that Jamaluddin owed Sikhs an apology.
Jamaluddin, who made the reference at a function in Ipoh, later admitted his mistake.
In Malaysia, Sikhs have been mistakenly referred to as Bengalis for decades, The Star newspaper said.
- Malay Sikhs refuse to back down on `Bengali identity comment - Apr 15, 2008
- Relatives can defend Malaysian Indian in sedition trial - Aug 22, 2009
- Malaysian Indian legislator quits party - Jun 15, 2010
- Malaysian court settles issue of chief minister's position - Feb 09, 2010
- Malaysian Indian legislator quits party (Lead) - Jun 15, 2010
- Ruling reserved on sedition charge against Malaysian Indian lawyer - Apr 22, 2009
- Called Bengalis, Malaysian Sikhs walk out of function - Apr 14, 2008
- Malaysian Indian leader calls for anti-defection law - Jun 16, 2010
- Malay Sikhs ask Malaysian Govt to declare Vaisakhi as a national holiday - Apr 08, 2010
- Hindu temple faces demolition in Malaysia - Dec 11, 2009
- Malaysian PM, other leaders condemn arson attacks on three churches - Jan 08, 2010
- Malaysian Indians moving away from opposition alliance: Report - Apr 06, 2011
- Malaysia's Democratic Action Party urged to revive Indian bureau - Jun 26, 2010
- More Sikh trainers for Malaysia's National Service - Jan 25, 2011
- Malaysian National Service to recruit more Sikh trainers to address problems of community - Jan 25, 2011