SC declines to stay Andhra court order against sub-quota (Second Lead)June 13th, 2012 - 4:34 pm ICT by IANS
New Delhi/Hyderabad, June 13 (IANS) In a major setback for the Congress-led United Progressive Alliance (UPA) central government, the Supreme Court Wednesday rejected its plea to stay an Andhra Pradesh High Court verdict quashing a 4.5 percent sub-quota for religious minorities.
An apex court bench of Justice K.S. Radhakrishnan and Justice J.S. Khehar said the 4.5 precent sub-quota within the 27 percent reservation for the Other Backward Classes (OBCs) was “not in conformitywith Article 15 of the Constitution”.
The court questioned the government whether it can provide a quota on the basis of religion.
The centre had issued an Office Memorandum (OM) on Dec 22, 2011 providing the sub-quota for minorities in jobs and central educational institutions like the IITs. The apex court, however, said the OM had no constitutional and statutory support.
The bench was not satisfied with the data and the documents submitted by the human resource development ministry to make a case for a sub-quota. The court had June 11 directed the ministry to place before it the material it relied on while creating the sub-quota.
The court order could affect the admission of students from the minority community to the IITs. As many as 325 candidates have been short-listed under the sub-quota for counseling after this year’s joint entrance examination.
The human resource development ministry had challenged the May 28 order of Andhra Pradesh High Court quashing the sub-quota.
The bench, comprising then Chief Justice Madan B. Lokur and Justice P.V. Sanjay Kumar, declared that this action of the central government was based upon religious lines and not on any other intelligible consideration.
The high court, which was dealing with a petition by backward classes welfare association, had also expressed deep anguish at the casual manner in which the issue was dealt by the central government and said that it had exceeded constitutional boundaries.
The high court opined that the OM violates Article 15 (1) and 16 (2) of the Indian constitution which prohibit discrimination based on religion.
The centre had issued OM ahead of the January-March assembly elections in Uttar Pradesh and four other states.
- SC declines to stay Andhra court order against sub-quota (Third Lead) - Jun 13, 2012
- Supreme Court no to stay Andhra court sub-quota order (Lead) - Jun 13, 2012
- No stay on sub-quota quashing to hit 325 IIT aspirants - Jun 13, 2012
- Court quashes 4.5 percent sub-quota for minorities (Lead) - May 28, 2012
- Will challenge sub-quota denial in apex court: Khurshid (Lead) - May 29, 2012
- SC to hear Monday government plea on minorities' sub-quota - Jun 09, 2012
- Apex Court refuses to suspend order on minority sub-quota - Jun 11, 2012
- Government files documents on minority sub-quota plea - Jun 12, 2012
- Government to move SC against quota decision - May 29, 2012
- Apex court refuses to suspend order on minority sub-quota (Lead) - Jun 11, 2012
- Government fooling minorities on reservation: BJP - May 29, 2012
- BJP hails apex court decision on minority quota - Jun 11, 2012
- Congress was never serious about Muslim quota: Azam Khan - Jun 14, 2012
- Minority quota a poll stunt: BJP - Dec 23, 2011
- Cabinet approves 4.5 percent minority quota (Third Lead) - Dec 22, 2011
Tags: andhra pradesh high court, apex court, casual manner, central government, chief justice, constitutional boundaries, court bench, court verdict, development ministry, educational institutions, entrance examination, human resource development, minority community, progressive alliance, religious lines, religious minorities, s radhakrishnan, sanjay kumar, statutory support, welfare association