Probe Batla House shootout for ‘transparency’: high courtApril 23rd, 2009 - 9:25 pm ICT by IANS
New Delhi, April 23 (IANS) Suggesting a magisterial inquiry into the controversial Batla House shootout last year, the Delhi High Court Thursday said the government’s reluctance in conducting the probe “might create suspicion” over the police version in the case.
“The more the government hardens its stand, the more suspicion it might create,” a bench comprising Chief Justice Ajit Prakash Shah and Justice Neeraj Kishan Kaul said.
Additional Solicitor General (ASG) Gopal Subramaniam, appearing for the government, vehemently opposed the idea of conducting the magisterial probe, prompting the court to say it was to bring in transparency.
“It is to bring transparency by conducting such an inquiry… This is the minimum protection (against human rights violations),” the court said and asked the solicitor to take instruction from the government on the issue.
Two suspected terrorists and a police inspector were killed Sep 18, 2008 last year - a week after serial bombings rocked the capital killing 26 people.
The court, however, made it clear that the report of the inquiry, if conducted, would not be used for any other proceeding and would be submitted before the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) which would decide on further course of action on the basis of finding.
“Take instruction from the government. The inquiry is only a fact-finding exercise and its report would not be used by any other body. The NHRC will look into the report and would decide what is to be done,” the court said while adjourning the matter for May 4.
The remark came on a petition by an NGO, Act Now For Harmony and Democracy (ANHAD), which has demanded a judicial probe into the shootout.
Delhi Police counsel Mukta Gupta had told the court in the last hearing that a magisterial probe would have “demoralising impact” on the police force.
- NHRC insists on magisterial probe into Batla House shootout - Apr 15, 2009
- Court favours independent probe into Batla House shootout - May 14, 2009
- Truth behind shootout must come out: court - Apr 08, 2009
- Batla House fit case for magisterial probe: NHRC - Mar 18, 2009
- Government queried on revoking Vectra choppers' licence - May 16, 2012
- Fresh setback for Modi, probe ordered into more fake shootouts (Lead) - Jan 25, 2012
- Court's no to another probe into Batla House shootout (Second Lead) - Aug 26, 2009
- Apex court says no to probe into Batla house killings (Lead) - Oct 30, 2009
- Court seeks response from NHRC on Batla House shootout - Mar 04, 2009
- Are confidential files without notings, asks SC - Aug 29, 2012
- Cash-for-votes scandal: Apex court rebukes Delhi Police (Lead) - Aug 05, 2011
- Gujarat opposes shifting Sadiq Jamal killing probe to CBI - Apr 06, 2011
- Bihar Deputy CM in trouble over police firing - Jun 10, 2011
- Strong proof against 13 cops in Sohrabuddin killing: Shah (Lead) - Nov 17, 2011
- Bihar engineer in Saudi custody: Government to SC (Second Lead) - Jul 09, 2012