No need to make emergency documents public: CourtJuly 12th, 2011 - 10:26 pm ICT by IANS
New Delhi, July 12 (IANS) The Delhi High Court Tuesday stayed a Central Information Commission’s (CIC) order to the president’s office to make public all documents on declaration of the emergency in 1975 by the then president Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed, including communications from the then prime minister Indira Gandhi.
Justice Rajiv Sahai Endlaw issued a notice to S.C. Aggarwal, a right to information (RTI) applicant, and stayed the CIC’s order till its further direction is passed.
The court issued notice after taking note of the submission of central public information officer (CPIO) of Rashtrapati Bhavan before the court that the documents were classified and privileged.
“The president’s secretariat is not liable to reveal the information and the CIC has no jurisdiction in law to pass such a direction,” said the CPIO.
The CPIO also said that the CIC failed to bear in mind that the information it asked to disclose directly related to the records of the office of the president.
In doing so, the CIC failed to appreciate the scope of protection under article 74 of the constitution.
On June 15, the CIC asked the Rashtrapati Bhavan to make public all documents related to the declaration of the emergency.
The Rashtrapati Bhavan refused to disclose any information related to the advice tendered by Gandhi to Ahmed on the imposition of the emergency.
“The question whether any, and if so what, advice was tendered by ministers to the president shall not be enquired into in any court,” the Rashtrapati Bhavan said, citing constitutional provisions.
According to the CIC order, the emergency was a challenge to India’s commitment to democracy and was symbolised by curtailment of fundamental rights of citizens, restrictions on the freedom of press, illegal detention, abuse of citizens and enactment of draconian laws.
- Court blocks Narayanan-Vajpayee letters on Gujarat riots (Lead) - Jul 11, 2012
- Court stays transparency panel's order against CBI - Jul 28, 2011
- Won't make public records on emergency: President's secretariat - Aug 31, 2010
- Is CIC empowered to prosecute for perjury? Court issues notice - Dec 23, 2011
- No disclosure of names of donors to PM's relief fund: Court - Jul 06, 2012
- Court stays order to make president's donations public - Jul 13, 2012
- PMO gets CIC notice over ministers' assets - Sep 06, 2010
- Emergency records missing from PMO - Mar 21, 2012
- Petition inquiring Sonia Gandhi's religion dismissed - Nov 29, 2010
- President comes under RTI, make donations public: Court (Lead) - Jun 14, 2012
- Governor not in RTI ambit? Court asks for affidavit - Jul 18, 2011
- Transparency panel's order on Supreme Court cases stayed (Lead) - Sep 13, 2011
- Donations by president: Information panel's order stayed - May 29, 2012
- Notice to government on plea for appointments in RTI ambit - Mar 28, 2011
- Court blocks Narayanan-Vajpayee letters on Gujarat riots - Jul 11, 2012
Tags: cic, constitutional provisions, cpio, curtailment, delhi high court, draconian laws, emergency documents, enactment, freedom of press, fundamental rights, illegal detention, imposition, indira gandhi, information commission, office of the president, prime minister indira, public information officer, rajiv, rashtrapati bhavan, sahai