Lawyers at centre-stage during impeachment debate
August 19th, 2011 - 1:23 am ICT by IANS
New Delhi, Aug 18 (IANS) The historic debate in the Rajya Sabha on the motion for removing from office Justice Soumitra Sen of Calcutta High Court saw legal lumaniries at their oratorical best in supporting the measure - with a lone voice of dissent.
The Bharatiya Janata Party viewpoint on supporting the motion was articulated by some of its best known faces - Arun Jaitley, Ram Jethmalani and Ravi Shankar Prasad - all of whom are lawyers.
The Congress was represented by E. M. Sudarsana Natchiappan, who too is a lawyer. The party supported the motion.
However, Satish Chandra Misra of Bahujan Samaj Party said the motion should be rejected. Misra, who is a noted lawyer from Uttar Pradesh, began by narrating how his chances of being elevated as a judge were scuttled by a letter of a former state chief minister.
Misra added in lighter vein that his not being a member of judiciary paved the way for his entering politics and he thanked the former chief minister for his letter after becoming member of the Rajya Sabha.
The DMK, AIADMK, Nationalist Congress Party and Biju Janata Dal also conveyed their viewpoint through their members who are lawyers.
All the speeches were heard in rapt attention. Unlike many other discussions in the house, the debate on the impeachment motion that stretched two days and six hours did not see interruptions.
Communist Party of India-Marxist (CPI-M) member Sitaram Yechury, who had moved the motion, later admitted he was impressed by richness of the debate.
“When occasion demands, the house has risen to the ocassion,” he said.
Unlike Wednesday, when the house was packed to strength to listen to Justice Sen’s defence, the attendance was relatively less when the debate resumed Thursday afternoon. However, the members were present in strength at the time of voting.
Though all speeches received bipartisan support, Jaitley’s point about judicial activism and need to respect separation of powers drew special applause from treasury benches and Prime Minister Manmohan Singh.
Some members from Lok Sabha also came to witness the debate in the gallery marked for them.
- Rajya Sabha makes history; votes for Justice Sen's impeachment (Third Lead) - Aug 19, 2011
- Rajya Sabha creates history; votes for Justice Sen's impeachment (Second Lead) - Aug 18, 2011
- Impeachment proceedings against Justice Sen begin - Aug 17, 2011
- Rajya Sabha votes to impeach Justice Soumitra Sen (Lead) - Aug 18, 2011
- Rajya Sabha resumes impeachment debate - Aug 18, 2011
- Soumitra Sen accepts Lok Sabha's stand - Sep 06, 2011
- Impeachment proceedings: Justice Sen claims innocence (Lead) - Aug 17, 2011
- Justice Soumitra Sen's impeachment: What next? - Aug 19, 2011
- Jaitley seeks new commission to appoint judges - Aug 19, 2011
- Lok Sabha likely to take up Justice Sen impeachment - Sep 03, 2011
- 'Decide impeachment in accordance with conscience' (Second Lead) - Aug 17, 2011
- Rajya Sabha panel holds Justice Sen guilty of corruption - Nov 10, 2010
- Patil forwards Sen's resignation for notification - Sep 03, 2011
- Apex court dismisses plea on Soumitra Sen impeachment - Nov 25, 2011
- Lok Sabha drops impeachment motion against Sen - Sep 05, 2011
Tags: aiadmk, bahujan samaj party, bharatiya janata party, calcutta high court, communist party of india, communist party of india marxist, entering politics, impeachment debate, impeachment motion, judicial activism, lone voice, misra, nationalist congress party, rajya sabha, ram jethmalani, rapt attention, ravi shankar, sitaram yechury, state chief, voice of dissent