Insurance firm must pay despite breach of conditions: courtMay 11th, 2008 - 10:23 pm ICT by admin
New Delhi, May 11 (IANS) The Supreme Court has ruled that the owner of a vehicle, plying it as a taxi flouting an insurance condition, will still be entitled to 75 percent of the insured sum on its theft or carjacking. A bench of Justice Tarun Chatterjee and Justice Dalveer Bhandari gave the ruling, upholding a September 2006 verdict of the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission.
The bench held that an insurance company was under obligation to indemnify the insurer for the theft of a vehicle, even if there was a breach of conditions of insurance. The ruling was given Thursday but released later.
“In the case of theft of a vehicle, breach of condition is not germane. The insurance company is liable to indemnify the owner of the vehicle when the insurer has obtained comprehensive policy for the loss,” the bench ruled.
The apex court gave the verdict while dismissing an appeal by the National Insurance Company against the consumer court which ordered it to pay 75 percent of the insured amount to Nitin Khandelwal, a resident of Gwalior in Madhya Pradesh.
Khandelwal had lost his vehicle, a Mahindra Scorpio bought in May 2003, in a carjacking incident en route to Jaipur in September.
When he lodged the claim for the insured sum, the insurance company dismissed it, saying he had been using the vehicle as taxi and flouted the conditions of insurance.
Though the Gwalior District Consumer Dispute Redressal Forum upheld the insurance company’s contention, the Madhya Pradesh State Consumer Forum on an appeal from Khandelwal directed it to pay 75 percent of the insured amount to the claimant.
- Arrest warrant against Mukesh Ambani by Kerala consumer court - Dec 16, 2011
- Non-advocates can appear before consumer forums: Apex court - Aug 31, 2011
- Insurance firm asked to pay for stolen truck, with interest - Nov 16, 2009
- Court pulls up consumer panel for overstepping powers - Jan 16, 2010
- Court refuses to stay Delhi vehicle number plate drive (Lead) - May 01, 2012
- Car thief's police custody extended - Jan 27, 2012
- Rs.10 lakh for family of accident victim - Sep 23, 2011
- Haryana doctor gets fire insurance claim after 10 years (Lead) - Jun 03, 2011
- Vehicle insurance can be claimed even after ownership change: Court - Nov 21, 2008
- Consumer court pulls up Lufthansa, orders fine - Aug 22, 2012
- Ban uninsured vehicles, court urged (Lead) - Sep 12, 2012
- Insurance firm asked to pay Rs.5 lakh for misleading consumer - Jun 30, 2011
- Honeymoon murder: Shrien Dewani to be extradited to South Africa - Aug 10, 2011
- Can't fleece plot seekers, consumer court warns land agencies - Jul 26, 2012
- Maid killed in accident, kin to get Rs. 9 lakh in damages - Sep 22, 2011