India’s nuclear deterrence lacks capability: AnalystJune 14th, 2010 - 8:41 pm ICT by IANS
New Delhi, June 14 (IANS) India’s nuclear deterrence lacks capability and the country needs to build up its stockpile of fissile material to correct this, a leading defence analyst said Monday.
“We need to build up our fissile material stockpiles because our deterrence lacks capability,” Brig. (retd) Gurmeet Kanwal said at a seminar here on “Nuclear Arsenals post 2010″ organised by the Indian Navy-funded National Maritime Foundation.
Kanwal noted in this context that India lacked nuclear submarines capable of launching SLBMs (submarine-launched ballistic missiles) that are considered the most credible form of deterrence in case of a nuclear attack.
As Rear Admiral (retd) K. Raja Menon put it, an SLBM “is the most stabilising element of a second strike capability” in case of a nuclear attack.
India has repeatedly said that it would not be the first to use nuclear weapons in case of a war with Pakistan but experts point out that given its limited delivery capabilities of delivering these from the air or from the ground, this would make the country vulnerable in case of war.
Urging greater transparency in the decision making process on building a credible deterrence against a nuclear attack, he deprecated the fact that the armed forces were kept out of the process.
“The armed forces stay out of the discussions because they take their lead from their political masters. Transparency leads to greater credibility,” maintained Kanwal, who heads the Indian Army-funded think tank Centre for Land Warfare Studies (CLAWS).
Bharat Karnad, another analyst, concurred with Kanwal.
“Much of the strategising (on countering a nuclear threat) is done outside of the armed forces. But then, the Indian military mirrors the political confusion in the country,” he said.
“There is too much of nuancing rather than getting about making a deterrent a deterrent,” he added.
- After delays, Scorpene submarine now on track: Navy chief - Dec 02, 2010
- China must strengthen its nuclear capabilities, says daily - Sep 07, 2012
- Putin, Obama agree to continue missile talks - Jun 19, 2012
- Bulava missile dangerous for Russia: Experts - Feb 21, 2012
- Pakistan warns against growing international support for India's nuclear programme - Jan 26, 2011
- Nukes needed to deter blackmail by other powers: India (Lead) - Aug 21, 2012
- Missiles of the world - a look at countries' arsenals - Apr 19, 2012
- 'Paranoid' about India, Pakistan desperate to expand its nuclear arsenal - Jan 28, 2011
- US deploys more missiles than Russia - Oct 26, 2011
- India's n-submarine Arihant to be commissioned 2012 (Lead) - Dec 02, 2010
- Pakistan has 100 n-weapons; edges ahead of India: Report - Jan 31, 2011
- Pakistan to become world's fourth-largest nuclear arsenal state by end of decade: Expert - Mar 31, 2011
- Russia to build balanced nuclear missile force by 2050 - Jul 26, 2009
- Russia to resume tests of submarine-launched missile - Sep 03, 2010
- N-capable missiles in India's arsenal [To go with India test-fires 5,000 km Agni-V missile, China cautious (Roundup) - Apr 19, 2012
Tags: ballistic missiles, defence analyst, delivery capabilities, gurmeet, indian army, indian military, indian navy, kanwal, land warfare, nuclear arsenals, nuclear attack, nuclear deterrence, nuclear submarines, political confusion, political masters, raja menon, rear admiral, slbm, strike capability, warfare studies