If prosecution case solid, hostile witnesses don’t matter: Court
October 21st, 2010 - 8:45 pm ICT by IANSNew Delhi, Oct 21 (IANS) The Supreme Court has held that even if all witnesses turn hostile a trial court can convict and sentence the accused, if the prosecution is successful in establishing their guilt.
If the prosecution case is strong then “eye witnesses turning hostile, do not, in any way, create a dent in the case of the prosecution”, said the apex court bench of Justice P. Sathasivam and Justice Anil R. Dave in their judgment Wednesday.
The court declined to accept the contention of counsel for murder accused Rameshbhai Mohanbhai Koli and others that since all the eye witnesses examined by the prosecution turned hostile, their statement could not be relied upon in the absence of other cogent, convincing and reliable evidence.
Speaking for the bench, Justice Sathasivam said “…all the eye-witnesses examined on the prosecution side have en bloc turned hostile due to influence and pressure of accused persons which included a sitting legislator of the ruling party”.
In the present case, chairman of Morbi Nagrik Bank Prakashbhai Raveshia was murdered over a decade ago, the prosecution said.
He along with bank director Ashokbhai Laljibhai Kathrani came out of their bank building and soon after, appellant Koli approached Prakashbhai Raveshia and inquired about loan facility. Then he exhorted other appellants to attack Raveshia.
Raveshia suffered injuries on account of the knife-attack and succumbed to injuries.
The trial court awarded life imprisonment to Koli and three others. This was confirmed by the Gujarat High Court. The apex court too upheld the conviction and sentencing of the appellants by the trial court in 2004.
The judgment said: “On going through the entire materials, the chain of circumstances, we are satisfied that the prosecution has been successful in bringing home the guilt of the appellant herein for the commission of murder of Prakashbhai Raveshia and the eye witnesses turning hostile, do not, in any manner, create a dent in the case of the prosecution.”
Referring to the earlier pronouncements of the apex court, the judgment said that “witnesses may lie but circumstances do not”.
- Apex court refuses to give relief to don Abu Salem (Lead) - Sep 10, 2010
- Salem's trial for murder: Apex court clears way for verdict (Second Lead) - Oct 05, 2010
- Pushkin Chandra killing: Life term for two upheld - Oct 31, 2011
- Parts of hostile witness's evidence can be used: Apex court (Lead) - May 22, 2012
- Nithari killings: Apex court sends Koli to the gallows (Third Lead) - Feb 15, 2011
- Ayodhya demolition behind 1993 Mumbai blasts, apex court told - Nov 01, 2011
- Court upholds life term for man who raped, killed daughter - Oct 23, 2011
- Shivani Bhatnagar murder: Ex-cop R.K. Sharma walks free - Oct 12, 2011
- Evidence of hostile witness carries weight: Apex court - May 22, 2012
- Witnesses turning hostile has become endemic: High court (Lead) - Mar 15, 2011
- Nithari killings: Apex court confirms death for Koli (Second Lead) - Feb 15, 2011
- Verdict on appeal of Shivani murder case convicts Wednesday - Oct 11, 2011
- Sheep thief acquitted of charge of shepherd's murder - Feb 02, 2011
- Three year jail for Mumbai hit-and-run convict: Apex court (Third Lead) - Jan 12, 2012
- Witnesses turning hostile has become endemic: High court - Mar 15, 2011
Tags: anil, apex, apex court, bank director, bringing home, case chairman, contention, court bench, eye witnesses, gujarat high court, hostile witnesses, knife attack, koli, legislator, life imprisonment, loan facility, morbi, prosecution case, ruling party, trial court