Forced to think of guidelines for social sites: Sibal
December 9th, 2011 - 4:45 pm ICT by IANS
New Delhi, Dec 9 (IANS) Communications Minister Kapil Sibal Friday said he was compelled to think of guidelines for barring objectionable content on social networking sites after they declined to do anything about the issue.
“It was not my intent ever to interfere with the social media. I wanted them to evolve their own guidelines. But if somebody throws up their hands we will have to evolve some guidelines,” Sibal said.
“I wanted a solution, a dialogue with them and deal with this issue in a sensible responsible manner,” the minister told Karan Thapar’s Devil’s Advocate programme on CNN-IBN.
The Internet world was in an uproar earlier this week after a news report said that Sibal had asked social networking sites like Facebook and Google, which operate the social video platform Youtube, to censor content which was offensive to religious sentiments and degrading some individuals.
The minister said he and his ministry officials had met representatives of the sites as many as six times since September but the companies had not come up with any solutions.
“Orally they agreed to do something, didn’t agree with something. But they did not commit. On Dec 5, they threw up their hands saying ‘we can’t deal with any of this at our end and we will apply US community standards’,” said Sibal.
Sibal clarified that he did not want platforms to screen content before it was uploaded, but wanted them to check for objectionable content.
As the controversy raged, Google has said there is a need to differentiate between what is controversial and what is illegal, adding that anything that went against statute was removed by their team, including content that went against their strict terms and conditions.
“But it also means that when content is legal but controversial, we don’t remove it because people’s differing views should be respected, so long as they are legal,” a Google spokesperson said in a statement.
In his response to this, Sibal said: “We have no problem with that except that they themselves accept that this content cannot be legal. They were failing to live up to the laws that they are enforcing in their own country by their own community standards.”
The minister said he would call for a roundtable on Dec 15 for evolving guidelines on the issue.
- Draw line between objectionable and controversial, say websites - Dec 06, 2011
- Sibal meets social media companies over content screening - Dec 15, 2011
- Scrap derogatory content by Feb 6, court asks websites (Third Lead) - Dec 24, 2011
- Netizens tweet foul as India targets 'objectionable' content - Dec 06, 2011
- Need to utilise laws to remove defamatory material: Assocham - Dec 07, 2011
- Social media code: Congress cautious, BJP opposes Sibal's way - Dec 08, 2011
- 'Why censor Facebook when you don't censor Sunny Leone?' - Dec 07, 2011
- Hate censorship, but freedom often misused: Omar - Dec 06, 2011
- All websites should operate within Indian laws: Pilot - Feb 07, 2012
- Government all for Internet freedom: NSA - May 16, 2012
- Foul content on websites hurts religious Indians, court told (Lead) - Feb 14, 2012
- Content screening: Facebook, others to reply in 15 days (Lead) - Feb 06, 2012
- Keeping check on social networking sites a challenge: Sibal - Sep 02, 2011
- Enforce law, don't gag social networking sites: Experts - Dec 12, 2011
- Court puts off hearing on Google, Facebook pleas (Lead) - Jan 19, 2012
Tags: cnn, cnn ibn, devil s advocate, facebook, google, internet world, kapil sibal, karan thapar, ministry officials, news report, objectionable content, religious sentiments, report said that, responsible manner, six times, social networking sites, spokesperson, strict terms, uproar, video platform