Deaf-mute can be credible witness: Apex court (Lead)May 21st, 2012 - 11:18 pm ICT by IANS
New Delhi, May 21 (IANS) The Supreme Court Monday said a deaf-mute need not be prevented from giving evidence in court merely on account of his physical disability as he can do so either by writing or through gestures.
The court said this while upholding the Rajasthan High Court’s verdict of May 29, 2005 by which it had quashed the conviction of murder accused Darshan Singh.
The apex court bench of Justice B.S. Chauhan and Justice Dipak Misra said: “…a dumb person need not be prevented from being a credible and reliable witness merely due to his/her physical disability. Such a person though unable to speak may convey himself through writing if literate or through signs and gestures if he is unable to read and write.”
“Language is much more than words. Like all other languages, communication by way of signs has some inherent limitations, since it may be difficult to comprehend what the user is attempting to convey,” said the court.
Justice Chauhan said: “When a deaf and dumb person is examined in the court, the court has to exercise due caution and take care to ascertain before he is examined that he possesses the requisite amount of intelligence and that he understands the nature of an oath.”
The witness may be administered oath by appropriate means and that may also be with the assistance of an interpreter, said Justice Chauhan.
In case a person can read and write it was most desirable to adopt a method that was more satisfactory than any sign language. “The law required that there must a record of signs and not the interpretation of signs,” the court said.
Finding no infirmity in a dumb witness tendering evidence, the court said that the object of enacting the provisions of Section 119 of the Indian Evidence Act reveals that deaf and dumb people were earlier contemplated in law as idiots.
“However, such a view has subsequently been changed for the reason that modern science revealed that persons affected with such calamities are generally found more intelligent, and to be susceptible to far higher culture than one was once supposed,” said the court.
To buttress its conclusion, the court referred to the era of silent movies where the theme of the film was expressed through gestures and the expression and was widely understood by the audiences.
Darshan Singh was sentenced to life term in 2003 for killing Kuku Singh on the evidence of the victim’s deaf-mute widow Geeta. The high court set aside the trial court’s conviction, giving the benefit of the doubt to Darshan Singh.
- Why Pakistanis in jail if sentence over: SC - Apr 10, 2012
- Why Pakistanis still in jail if sentence over: Apex court (Lead) - Apr 10, 2012
- Deaf quicker at catching body language - Jan 13, 2012
- When Bollywood stars move closer to a silent world - Jun 16, 2011
- 'Barfi' not a silent film, says Anurag Basu - Jul 04, 2012
- IGNOU spreads awareness about deafness - May 27, 2012
- Deaf-mute athlete raped in Bengal, attacker arrested - Jun 26, 2012
- 'Barfi' was like dumb charades for me, says Ranbir Kapoor - Sep 01, 2012
- Programme converts sign language into text - Mar 12, 2012
- 'Soundtrack' remake of 'It's All Gone Pete Tong' - Apr 10, 2011
- IGNOU gives India first sign language training centre - Oct 04, 2011
- Matrimony, love breathe life into sounds of silence - May 02, 2010
- Same brain regions translate words and gestures - Nov 10, 2009
- Hong Kong deaf-mute love triangle killer jailed - Nov 17, 2009
- Charming, pure, 'Barfi!' a modern masterpiece (IANS Movie Review - Rating: ****) - Sep 14, 2012
Tags: apex, apex court, court bench, court justice, credible witness, dipak, due caution, dumb person, dumb witness, evidence act, evidence in court, gestures, giving evidence in court, infirmity, misra, modern science, more than words, physical disability, rajasthan high court, sign language