Court stays order to provide Tehelka report to Fernandes
July 22nd, 2011 - 10:20 pm ICT by IANSNew Delhi, July 22 (IANS) A Central Information Commission (CIC) order asking the defence ministry to provide a report on the Tehelka defence deal expose to former defence minister George Fernandes was stayed by the Delhi High Court Friday.
On Nov, 23, 2009, the CIC ordered the government to provide complete report of the Justice S.N. Phukan Commission of Inquiry, which probed the Tehelka expose on alleged corruption in defence deals, to Fernandes.
Putting stay on the CIC’s earlier direction, Justice Rajiv Sahai Endlaw said: “The operation of the CIC order is stayed.”
The court was hearing the petition filed by the defence ministry seeking quashing of CIC order, which directed the ministry to provide Fernandes a “complete copy” of the report of the Commission of Inquiry.
Approaching the court in appeal against CIC order, the ministry had clarified that since the complete report was not even tabled in parliament, it could not be provided to Fernandes.
The report cannot be given under the transparency law as it would also breach parliamentary privilege, it said.
Fernandes first approached the PMO on Feb 7, 2008 under the RTI Act seeking the copy of the panel’s report which had probed the Tehelka expose claiming corruption in defence deals during his tenure in the NDA regime.
The government, in its plea, said the information was denied to Fernandes also because of the fact that the CBI was then probing cases registered following the telecast of the sting operation.
- CIC asks government to give Phukan report to Fernandes - Nov 25, 2009
- Court stays transparency panel's order against CBI - Jul 28, 2011
- Court refuses to stop Bangaru Laxman's trial for graft - Aug 30, 2010
- Consider plea for CBI probe against Team Anna: Court (Lead) - May 30, 2012
- Why not asylum to Pakistani Hindus, court asks government - Dec 21, 2011
- Ex-judge moves high court over complaint against him - Feb 01, 2011
- Transparency panel's order on Supreme Court cases stayed (Lead) - Sep 13, 2011
- Court stays information panel's order on banks (Lead) - Dec 08, 2011
- Court refuses to stay probe against chess federation (Lead) - Nov 22, 2011
- No need to make emergency documents public: Court - Jul 12, 2011
- Government gets notice on information panel vacancies (Lead) - Dec 14, 2011
- Is CIC empowered to prosecute for perjury? Court issues notice - Dec 23, 2011
- Court wants early meeting of panel on media - Mar 07, 2012
- Order put off on Kalmadi's plea to attend parliament - Aug 01, 2011
- 'Monitor CBI probe in Kandla Port cam' - Apr 02, 2012
Tags: alleged corruption, cbi, cic, commission of inquiry, defence deals, defence minister george, defence ministry, delhi high court, george fernandes, information commission, New Delhi, parliamentary privilege, plea, pmo, rajiv, rti act, sahai, sting operation, tehelka, tenure