Court asks CBI if it can give Nandigram report to Bengal
October 25th, 2010 - 10:53 pm ICT by IANSNew Delhi, Oct 25 (IANS) The Supreme Court Monday asked the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) whether it was willing to share the report of its investigations into the 2007 Nandigram police firing with the West Bengal government.
The apex court bench of Justice R.V. Raveendran and Justice A.K. Patnaik asked the CBI to state its position after senior counsel K.K. Venugopal, appearing for the state government, said: “We must at least know who they are prosecuting and on what charges.”
Additional Solicitor General P.P. Malhotra, appearing for the CBI, opposed the plea.
He said that under the criminal procedure code only the accused could get the report that too after the charge sheet was filed. “The accused have no right to a copy in the stage of investigation,” he said.
Justice Raveendran said: “We only said submit a report to the high court. But we never said do it in a sealed cover and not give anybody a copy of the report.”
“Let’s draw a line of distinction between the police officials and the West Bengal government,” Justice Raveendran said.
Senior counsel Venugopal told the apex court that the high court ordered the CBI probe after it struck down the rules that permitted the state police to open fire on unruly mobs.
He said that in many states firing by police in air as a warning shot was not permitted.
The CBI has sought permission to prosecute police officials found guilty of opening fire March 14, 2007 in which 14 people were killed. The victims were protesting against the acquisition of their land.
The premier investigating agency was directed by the Calcutta High Court to probe the Nandigram police firing. The CBI has already submitted its report to the high court.
The state government moved the apex court against the high court order to the CBI. The apex court while refusing to stay the investigation, restrained the CBI from prosecution of the police personnel on the basis of its report.
The investigating agency moved the apex court seeking the vacation of the interim restrain order on going ahead with the prosecution. However, this is being opposed by the state government.
- Don't treat Bengal as accused in Nandigram firing, CBI told (Lead) - Oct 27, 2010
- Nandigram deaths: CBI seeks nod to book cops (Lead) - Sep 27, 2010
- Nandigram firing: CBI seeks court nod for booking cops - Aug 26, 2010
- Supreme Court notice to Kerala Police on Italian ship (Lead) - Apr 10, 2012
- Apex court allows Bengal to withdraw Nandigram plea - Feb 24, 2012
- Notice to West Bengal on Nandigram firing - Sep 27, 2010
- Supreme Court issues notice to West Bengal Government in Nandigram firing case - Sep 27, 2010
- Don't drag Chidambaram into 2G case, CBI tells apex court - Sep 20, 2011
- Government reluctant on U. Lalit's appointment in 2G case (Lead) - Apr 05, 2011
- Chidambaram favoured 2G auction, CBI tells apex court - Sep 29, 2011
- ED to attach assets of firms in 2G case (Lead) - Apr 27, 2011
- 2G scam, black money cases in apex court this week - Feb 07, 2011
- CBI bid to brand me as extortionist, Shah tells apex court - Jan 27, 2011
- Apex court setback to Bengal government on Netai killings - Mar 18, 2011
- CBI will study Swamy's documents on Chidambaram, court told (Lead) - Sep 22, 2011
Tags: apex, apex court, calcutta high court, cbi probe, central bureau of investigation, court bench, investigating agency, mobs, nandigram police, New Delhi, plea, police officials, prosecution, raveendran, senior counsel, solicitor general, state government, state police, warning shot, west bengal government