Army chief’s age: Ball back in defence ministry’s court
May 20th, 2011 - 1:58 am ICT by IANSNew Delhi, May 20 (IANS) The confusion regarding the correct age of Indian Army chief General V.K. Singh just got confounded with the country’s senior-most legal advisor Thursday recommending that any change in the date of birth at this stage should be “legally sustainable”, officials said here.
With this legal view from Attorney General Goolam E. Vahanvati, the ball is now in the defence ministry’s court on deciding the age of the present army chief, which could send the plan of succession to the 1.13-million strong army into a tizzy.
The defence ministry had sought the attorney general’s views on the date of birth of the army chief, as there were two different sets of records with the army headquarters with different dates of birth mentioned.
The issue came up earlier this year after a set of Right to Information (RTI) application sought details of his date of birth and the army referred the requests to the defence ministry.
The confusion over Gen. V.K. Singh’s age had cropped up in 2008 after the army’s military secretary branch records of his Union Public Service Commission applications showed his date of birth as May 10, 1950, while the adjutant general’s branch had May 10, 1951 on its records.
Military secretary handles appointments and promotions and adjutant general pay and pension.
If 1950 is maintained as Gen. Singh’s year of birth, then present Eastern Army Commander Lt. Gen. Bikram Singh would in all likelihood be the next chief. If 1951 is sustained, then Northern Army Commander Lt. Gen. K.T. Parnaik would be the next in line to take over from Gen. Singh.
On the basis of the RTI applications, the defence ministry had first asked the law ministry to give its opinion on this age confusion and it had in its reply, recommended that the school leaving certificate of the army chief would have to be taken as a legal document to certify the date of birth.
The school leaving certificate, however, shows 1951 as the year of Gen. Singh’s birth.
However, his appointment as the chief of the army staff was issued on the basis of the military secretary branch’s documents, which mention 1950 as the year of his birth.
With the attorney general now asking the defence ministry to decide on the age on the basis of facts that are sustainable in a court of law, it would now be Defence Minister A.K. Antony’s call.
- Antony shies away from army chief's age controversy - May 20, 2011
- Ministry rejection of chief's age plea legally unsound: Army - Sep 04, 2011
- Government to settle army chief age issue in court, not administratively - Jan 29, 2012
- Indian Army chief will retire in 2012, rules Antony - Jul 21, 2011
- Army rejects defence ministry's order on chief's age - Aug 23, 2011
- It's official: 1950 is army chief's year of birth (Timeline) - Feb 10, 2012
- Government reiterates order on Army chief's age issue, to settle case in court (Lead) - Jan 29, 2012
- 1950 or 1951? That's the vital question for Gen. V.K. Singh - Feb 09, 2012
- Decision on Indian Army chief's age soon: Antony - Apr 25, 2011
- Army chief's plea to change age rejected, to retire in May 2012 (Lead) - Dec 30, 2011
- Government has right to determine tenure: Army chief - Jan 18, 2012
- Army chief's age plea before Supreme Court Friday - Feb 09, 2012
- Supreme Court trips army chief in age row battle (Evening Lead) - Feb 10, 2012
- More trouble for army's former military secretary - Aug 23, 2011
- Army chief meets Mukherjee amid age row - Feb 02, 2012
Tags: adjutant general, army chief, army commander, army headquarters, bikram singh, chief general, date of birth, dates of birth, defence ministry, indian army, law ministry, leaving certificate, legal document, military secretary, New Delhi, northern army, public service commission, rti application, tizzy, union public service commission