Apex court to hear Friday Vodafone’s suit against tax demand
January 21st, 2009 - 10:29 pm ICT by IANS ( Leave a comment )New Delhi, Jan 21 (IANS) The Supreme Court is to hear Friday global telecom giant Vodafone’s lawsuit challenging a demand for $1.7 billion as income tax for acquiring stakes in another global telecom major Hutchison that also resulted in the company’s acquisition of Indian telecom service provider Hutch Essar.The Netherlands-based Vodafone’s suit challenges a Bombay High Court ruling justifying the income tax notice.
The Bombay High Court on Dec 3 last year had dismissed a petition by Vodafone International Holdings challenging the tax notice.
In its lawsuit in the apex court, Vodafone has raised a crucial legal question as to whether the acquisition of one foreign company by another foreign firm outside Indian shores, eventually resulting in indirect acquisition of an Indian firm, makes the foreign firm liable to pay income tax to the Indian tax authorities.
Vodafone had bought a 67 percent stake in Hutchison Essar from Hutchison Telecom International (HTIL) in February 2007 for $11.2 billion.
The I-T department had asked the telecom major to pay $1.7 billion as capital gains tax for the acquisition.
Vodafone had moved the Bombay High Court contending that the tax department had no jurisdiction over a deal between two parties incorporated overseas.
Vodafone had also contended that it had not directly acquired the shares of the India-incorporated Hutch-Essar.
The high court had said that Vodafone’s petition totally lacked “particulars as to the nature of agreement dated on February 11, 2007, and all other agreements preceding or following the same, entered into by Hutchison Telecommunications International (HTIL) and the petitioner (Vodafone International).
“The essential facts, supported by the necessary documents, have been conveniently kept away from this court,” it had ruled.
The high court, however, had given Vodafone eight weeks to file an appeal in the Supreme Court and had extended its earlier stay asking the I-T department not to proceed against Vodafone.
- Apex court tells Vodafone to deal with Income Tax department - Jan 23, 2009
- India's apex court saves Vodafone $2.2-bn tax burden (Roundup) - Jan 20, 2012
- Vodafone moves Supreme Court against tax claim - Apr 05, 2011
- Supreme Court asks Vodafone to deposit Rs.2,500 crore (Lead) - Nov 15, 2010
- Indian court dismisses Vodafone petition on $2.6 bn tax case - Sep 08, 2010
- Government studying court ruling on Vodafone tax dispute - Jan 25, 2012
- I-T authorities can dissect any takeover deal: Apex court - Aug 04, 2011
- Vodafone to take tax case to Supreme Court - Dec 05, 2008
- Vodafone tax verdict to impact on similar merger deals: experts - Jan 20, 2012
- Vodafone plea in $2.6-bn Indian tax case dismissed (Lead) - Sep 27, 2010
- Apex court adjourns Vodafone plea on income tax order (Lead) - Oct 25, 2010
- Nothing colourable in takeover, Vodafone tells apex court (Lead) - Aug 03, 2011
- Nothing colourable in takeover, Vodafone tells apex court - Aug 03, 2011
- Vodafone vows to defend position on tax issue - Sep 27, 2010
- Vodafone files petition against tax authorities move - Oct 15, 2010
Tags: apex, apex court, bombay high court, capital gains tax, giant vodafone, global telecom, hutch essar, hutchison essar, hutchison telecom international, hutchison telecommunications, indian telecom, jan 21, legal question, necessary documents, particulars, petitioner, tax authorities, telecom giant, telecom service provider, vodafone