Apex court reserves verdict on Jessica killer’s bail pleaApril 16th, 2008 - 11:45 pm ICT by admin
New Delhi, April 16 (IANS) The Supreme Court Wednesday reserved its verdict on the bail plea of Manu Sharma, convicted and sentenced to life in jail for killing ramp model Jessica Lall. A bench of Justice C.K. Thakkar and Justice D.K. Jain reserved its verdict after hearing arguments by Additional Solicitor General Gopal Subramanian opposing the bail and senior counsel Ram Jethmalani demanding it for Sharma.
Lall was shot dead at a south Delhi restaurant owned by socialite Bina Ramani on the intervening night of April 29-30, 1999. Sharma, son of former Haryana minister Venod Sharma, had opened fire at her for refusing to serve him a drink.
While arguing for bail to Sharma, Jethmalani went to the extent of casting aspersions on the character of the slain model.
“Whisky was not the motive (behind the killing). It was something else. The lady had promised something else but did not keep her word,” he said.
“Had whisky been the motive, the victim could have been some other bartender instead of her,” he added.
During his argument, Jethmalani questioned various pieces of evidence on the basis of which the Delhi High Court had convicted Sharma.
He contended that Sharma was eligible for bail as there was considerable delay in hearing his appeal filed against his conviction.
The senior advocate said the court only has to consider whether on grant of bail the accused will abscond. This, he said, was not likely, as he never violated the bail condition during the trial.
Jethmalani said the possibility that Sharma would be acquitted could not be ruled out as the trial court had absolved him of the crime but the high court reversed the decision.
Jethmalani contended that the high court verdict was perverse and in his view the “judgement of conviction is not entitled to be qualified as judgement”.
He alleged the case was foisted on Sharma and evidence was fabricated. This was proved by the fact that the forensic report confirmed that bullets were fired from two weapons, he said.
Opposing the bail plea, Subramanian supported the high court verdict, saying there was “no miscarriage of justice” and Sharma did not deserve bail.
The apex court had denied bail to Sharma last November.
- Verdict on Manu's plea in Jessica murder likely Monday - Apr 17, 2010
- Apex court upholds life for Manu Sharma in Jessica murder case (Lead) - Apr 19, 2010
- Apex court upholds life for Manu Sharma in Jessica murder case (Second Lead) - Apr 19, 2010
- Manu deserves life for killing Jessica: Apex court (Third Lead) - Apr 19, 2010
- Manu Sharma's parole plea decision Nov 16 (Lead) - Nov 14, 2011
- Jessica Lall case: Defence ends arguments in perjury case - Apr 19, 2011
- Jessica Lall case : Supreme Court rejects Manu Sharma's plea - Aug 10, 2010
- IPS officer's widow oppose Sen's bail plea (Lead) - Jan 25, 2011
- High court reserves order on Binayak Sen's bail plea (Second Lead) - Feb 09, 2011
- Supreme Court notice on IAS officer's bail plea - Oct 20, 2011
- Manu Sharma questions Bina Ramani's testimony in Jessica murder case - Jan 21, 2010
- Supreme Court verdict in Jessica Lall murder case today - Apr 19, 2010
- Manu Sharma seeks 12-day parole for brother's marriage (Lead) - Nov 02, 2011
- Final door closed for Manu Sharma: Jessica's sister - Apr 19, 2010
- Manu Sharma moves court for three weeks' furlough - Sep 07, 2012