Aarushi case: Arguments on charges inconclusive (Lead)May 22nd, 2012 - 7:34 pm ICT by IANS
Ghaziabad, May 22 (IANS) The initial arguments to frame charges against Rajesh and Nupur Talwar, the parents of murdered teenager Aarushi, remained inconclusive in a Ghaziabad court Tuesday even as the CBI claimed that the dentist couple killed their daughter in 2008.
Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) prosecutor R.K. Saini submitted before Special Judge S. Lal that the parents were responsible for killing their daughter and had “dressed up” the scene to cover up their crime. He cited this as the reason for charges to be framed against them.
Opposing the CBI plea, defence lawyer Vijay Pal Singh Rathi said: “The submission of the closure report itself is the evidence that there is no evidence against the Talwars. And most importantly, all the scientific tests conducted by the CBI go against the investigation agency. The CBI has failed to prove the crime. Neither the direct nor the circumstantial evidence support the CBI argument to frame the charges. Hence, Nupur and Rajesh Talwar should be discharged from the case.”
The arguments on framing of charges in the twin murders of Aarushi and her family’s domestic help, Hemraj, would continue Wednesday.
Defence lawyer Satyaketu Singh earlier told the court that the papers submitted by the investigation agency were deficient. He said out of the five mobile phone numbers, he could peruse details of only three numbers.
He said call details of two mobile numbers had not been furnished by the CBI to the accused.
On May 16, the court had deferred the hearing till Monday to allow the CBI to provide documents to Aarushi’s parents. The court had Monday deferred the hearing to Tuesday.
The sessions court started the trial May 11, almost four years after the crime.
Also on May 16, the Supreme Court had reserved its verdict on Nupur Talwar’s petition seeking review of its Jan 6 order directing her and Rajesh Talwar to stand trial for the twin murders.
An apex court bench of Justice A.K. Patnaik and Justice J.S. Khehar had reserved the verdict on the conclusion of arguments by senior counsel Pinaki Misra, appearing for Nupur Talwar.
Misra assailed a Ghaziabad magistrate court’s order that rejected the closure report filed by the CBI in the double murder and took cognizance of the charge against the Talwars.
The CBI filed its closure report in December 2010 before the magistrate’s court in Ghaziabad.
The Talwars are facing charges of murder, conspiracy and destruction of evidence.
Aarushi, 14, was found murdered at her parents’ Noida residence May 16, 2008. The body of her family’s domestic help Hemraj was found the next day on the terrace of the house.
- Aarushi case: Arguments on charges end, order Thursday (Lead) - May 23, 2012
- Framing of charges underway in Aarushi case - May 22, 2012
- Aarushi murder case adjourned till Tuesday (Second Lead) - May 21, 2012
- Aarushi case: Arguments on charges conclude, order Thursday - May 23, 2012
- Aarushi case: Hearing adjourned till Tuesday (Lead) - May 21, 2012
- SC notice to CBI on Nupur Talwar's bail plea (Lead) - Jul 16, 2012
- Talwars charged with Aarushi, Hemraj murders (Second Lead) - May 24, 2012
- Supreme Court reserves verdict on Nupur Talwar's plea (Lead) - May 16, 2012
- Talwars charged with Arushi, Hemraj murders (Lead) - May 24, 2012
- Nupur Talwar moves apex court for bail (Lead) - Jul 03, 2012
- CBI backs magistrate's stand against Talwars (Lead) - May 10, 2012
- Another night in jail for Nupur Talwar, bail decision Wednesday (Second Lead) - May 01, 2012
- In courts on daughter's fourth death anniversary - May 16, 2012
- CBI backs magistrate's stand against Talwars - May 10, 2012
- Talwars formally charged with murders - May 25, 2012
Tags: apex court, cbi, central bureau of investigation, circumstantial evidence, closure report, court bench, defence lawyer, domestic help, evidence support, initial arguments, investigation agency, lal, mobile numbers, mobile phone numbers, murders, nupur, rajesh, rathi, sessions court, special judge