Indian umpire to man review system, Strauss, Smith reveal doubts
December 16th, 2009 - 2:26 pm ICT by ANI ( Leave a comment )Cape Town (S. Africa), Dec. 16 (ANI): The review umpire at Centurion is one of the least experienced on the Test circuit, India’s Amiesh Saheba, who has stood in only two Tests and been TV umpire six times - but never in a match where the review system was being used.
Saheba’s presence is likely to make the captains of England and South Africa- Andrwew Strauss and Graeme Smith - more nervous. They have already expressed misgivings about the ICC umpire review system.
Under the controversial system, now meant to be in place for all Test cricket, teams can ask for a decision to be reviewed by the TV umpire using all technology available, including Hawk-Eye.
Both batsmen and bowlers can ask for the second opinion. But once a team have had two referrals rejected, that is their allocation used up for the innings.
The idea is that patently poor decisions over lbws and close catches are eliminated.
The ICC maintain the review system means 97 per cent of decisions will be correct compared to the average of 91 per cent under the traditional system.
The Daily Express however quoted Strauss as saying: “We have to trial it. There are some reservations and in some of the recent games where it has been used those reservations have not been erased.”
Smith said: “I have my doubts. It needs to prove its worth to me in this series. We had a few frustrations with it in the last series against Australia. We felt that it probably caused a few more frustrations than added value.” (ANI)
- Lbw decisions won't be reviewed in India-England series - Jul 20, 2011
- Australia will find Swann difficult to tackle: Emburey - Oct 26, 2010
- Shame that Hawk-Eye is not being used: Swann (Lead) - Jul 19, 2011
- Pakistan favours referral system in One-dayers - Oct 07, 2009
- Not using UDRS could backfire on India: Swann - Jun 15, 2011
- Shame that DRS won't be available for India series: Swann - Jul 19, 2011
- DRS back in spotlight in India-England series - Jul 31, 2011
- BCCI remains defiant on umpire decision review system - Oct 07, 2010
- Strauss remains sceptical about use of 'controversial' Umpiring Review System - Dec 03, 2010
- ICC guidelines on lbw review - Mar 07, 2011
- Umpire Decision Review System in ODIs is a must: Shahid Afridi - Sep 24, 2010
- England getting to understand Umpire Decision Review System better: Strauss - Aug 06, 2010
- Dar backs new umpire referral system - Nov 19, 2009
- India were not prepared for the first Test: Hussain - Jul 26, 2011
- India cannot ask for a greater occasion to stamp their authority (Comment) - Jul 20, 2011
Tags: added value, cape town, centurion, controversial system, cricket teams, daily express, frustrations, graeme smith, hawk, hawk eye, misgivings, poor decisions, recent games, referrals, second opinion, six times, strauss, test circuit, test cricket, tv umpire