‘Cat-with-nine-lives’ Swann cleared of drink-driving charge on legal technality
February 17th, 2011 - 12:45 pm ICT by ANILondon, Feb 17(ANI): England off-spinner Graeme Swann has been cleared of a drink-driving case involving a late-night bid to rescue a trapped cat.
Swann had earlier told the court that he had returned to his four-bedroom home in West Bridgford, Nottingham, following his birthday celebrations last April to discover that his nine-month-old cat Max was trapped under the floorboards.
He claimed that he jumped into his white Porsche Cayenne ‘in a panic’ and drove to a 24-hour Asda to buy tools to loosen the boards.
The 31-year-old was, however, stopped by police at 3a.m.
Swann gave two blood samples, and a reading of 83mg of alcohol per 100ml of blood was taken from the second. The legal limit is 80mg per 100ml.
Legal guidelines state that the reading should have been taken from the first sample.
Police said that the second was used because there was not enough blood in the first, but a forensic alcohol consultant told the court the original two ml was ‘ample’.
Ruling in Swann’s favour, district judge Julia Newton said that it had not been proven that the blood sample could be used as evidence.
“I cannot be sure the two millilitre sample was insufficient or incapable of analysis by ordinary means. It may have been possible to analyse. Therefore on the specific facts of this case I am not sure the crown can rely on the second sample of blood. The burden of proof is on the crown to prove the first sample was incapable of analysis,” Newton said.
Meanwhile, Nottinghamshire Police Chief Inspector Andrew Charlton said that his department respects the decision, but was disappointed that a very technical piece of legislation allowed the case to not go ahead and prevented a conviction.
“He has retained his licence on this occasion which is good for his career, but hopefully he will learn from this experience and never repeat this behaviour again,” the Daily Mail quoted Charlton, as saying.
“We hope the message goes that drink-driving is not acceptable no matter who you are. Swann is entitled to use the law to its fullest extent, as anyone is,” he added. (ANI)
- Swann blames drink-driving rap on "mercy mission" to rescue his trapped cat! - Aug 17, 2010
- Swann fails to get drink-drive charge dismissed in court - Dec 09, 2010
- Swann challenges blood test in drink-driving case - Feb 16, 2011
- Swann 'drove to get screwdriver for rescuing cat after drinking for five hours' - Oct 08, 2010
- Swann charged with drink-driving - Jul 20, 2010
- Adelaide hero Swann to face drink-drive trial at home - Dec 08, 2010
- Gazza's drink-driving charge dropped - Feb 11, 2011
- Witness' failure to attend court delays Gazza 'drik-driving' care for 3rd time - Dec 14, 2010
- One alcoholic drink can triple chances of car accident - Jun 18, 2010
- 72pc of all alcohol-related deaths on NZ roads caused by 'problem drivers' - Nov 14, 2010
- Gazza may be jailed for druk driving - Nov 11, 2010
- Gazza's eight-week jail sentence suspended by Newcastle court - Dec 10, 2010
- Brit man on dance drug dies after downing pint of vodka in 4 seconds - Sep 30, 2010
- Delhi Police anti-drinking drive to continue after Holi - Mar 05, 2012
- Posthumous Amy Winehouse album to be released in December - Oct 31, 2011
Tags: 100ml, andrew charlton, asda, birthday celebrations, blood sample, blood samples, burden of proof, cat max, cat with nine lives, chief inspector, daily mail, district judge, floorboards, julia newton, london feb, millilitre, police chief, porsche cayenne, spinner, west bridgford nottingham