Mukhtaran gangrape accused’s acquittal seen as setback to women’s rights in PakistanApril 22nd, 2011 - 1:37 pm ICT by ANI
Lahore, April 22(ANI): The acquittal of five of the six accused in the Mukhtaran Mai gangrape case by Pakistan’s Supreme Court is being seen as a setback to women’s rights in the country.
Mai was gang raped on the orders of a village council in 2002 as a punishment because her 12-year-old brother was judged to have offended the honour of a powerful clan by allegedly having an affair with one of its women, although villagers say that the boy was merely seen walking with the girl.
Mai became a national and international symbol of the then almost nonexistent women’s rights movement in Pakistan, when she spoke out against her attackers following her ordeal in 2002.
However, Pakistan’s Supreme Court acquitted five of the six accused in the gang rape case yesterday as it upheld the verdict of the Lahore High Court (LHC) in a highly watched decision, which critics say will set back the struggle for women’s rights, the Christian Science Monitor reports.
Thursday’s verdict not only has a “negative impact on civil society organizations that are trying to improve the condition of women,” but also highlights weak collection of evidence by the police that allows serious criminals as well as terrorists to walk free, said Mehdi Hasan, former chairman of the independent Human Rights Commission of Pakistan (HRCP).
“During the last four years in serious crimes like terrorism, 98 per cent of accused have been acquitted,” said Hasan, citing HRCP research.
The apex court’s detailed judgment cites lack of DNA testing as a reason for acquitting the men.
“The entire case fell apart on lack of evidence. There was no corroboration of statements, various things were missing. The police in this country are not sensitized to deal with rape victims,” said lawyer and talk-show host Ayesha Tammy Haq, adding that police reform is crucial to bringing culprits to justice.
“In a country like Pakistan, where women don’t even dare to report rape because of the taboo attached to it, our judiciary sets rapists free,” tweeted Mehmal Sarfraz, a Lahore-based journalist.
Still, in the nine years since Mai took up the cause, her case has helped embolden women in Pakistan, the report said, adding that although rape is rarely reported in the country, at least 2,903 women came forward with rape complaints last year, depicting a significant increase from those recorded in 2005, according to the HRCP. (ANI)
- Pakistan to provide security, assistance to Mukhtaran Mai - Apr 22, 2011
- Mukhtaran Mai verdict a disappointment: Sherry Rehman (Lead) - Apr 22, 2011
- Mukhtaran Mai verdict a disappointment: Sherry Rehman - Apr 22, 2011
- Pakistan's apex court acquits five in Mukhtaran Mai rape case - Apr 21, 2011
- Mukhtaran Mai fears being killed after Pak Supreme Court acquits rape accused - Apr 22, 2011
- Mukhtaran Mai rape verdict deeply disappointing: Pakistani daily - Apr 23, 2011
- Pak Supreme Court acquits five of six accused in Mukhtaran Mai gang rape case - Apr 21, 2011
- Mukhtaran Mai gang rape: 13 released after acquittal - Apr 27, 2011
- Mukhtaran Mai abused her power: WikiLeaks - Jun 13, 2011
- Pak Govt to provide security, legal aid to Mukhtaran Mai for case review - Apr 23, 2011
- Pak SC judge writes dissenting note in Mukhtaran Mai gangrape case - Apr 22, 2011
- Gang-rape victim Mukhtaran Mai weds police constable in her native village - Mar 16, 2009
- Protect your women, girls: EU tells Pakistan, Afghanistan - Dec 17, 2011
- Canadian university to award honorary doctorate to Mukhtar Mai - Jun 11, 2010
- 'Shariat Court verdict seeking reversal of provisions discriminatory against Pak women' - Dec 26, 2010
Tags: apex court, christian science monitor, civil society organizations, condition of women, corroboration, dna testing, gang rape case, hrcp, human rights commission, human rights commission of pakistan, independent human rights, international symbol, lack of evidence, lahore high court, lhc, pakistan lahore, police reform, rape victims, serious crimes, talk show host