Indian youth defy superstition, eat during eclipse
January 15th, 2010 - 10:48 pm ICT by IANS ( 5 comments )Bangalore, Jan 15 (IANS) Hundreds of young Indians in this IT capital defied superstition and treated themselves to a sumptuous lunch during the millennium’s longest annular eclipse Friday.
The Jawaharlal Nehru Planetarium (JNP) in downtown, which was a beehive of activity during the four-hour celestial act, not only hosted a free lunch for about 200 volunteers, but also allowed supply of snacks and tea to the public that thronged its campus to watch the event.
“We have not restricted anyone from taking food in the campus. On the contrary, we arranged lunch for volunteers and our staff to demonstrate that there was no scientific basis for not eating during the eclipse,” JNP senior director C.S. Shukre told IANS.
Though eatables were not allowed inside the planetarium, a majority in the crowd, especially students of schools and colleges, mocked at the older and the conservatives for perpetuating the myth that consuming food during solar or lunar eclipse was bad for health and their future.
“What has eclipse got to do with eating food or other daily habits? It’s all humbug spread by ignorant and blind believers. Am shocked to know that even the educated are not free from such superstition,” lamented H. Gopal (25), an engineering graduate who came to the planetarium to watch the event.
Echoing Gopal, Kavyashree and Anusha, science under-graduates from MES and KLE colleges in the city, said they too didn’t believe in the myth and were happy to join their friends at lunch even as the moon was gobbling the sun in the distant sky.
“We don’t believe in superstitions. Luckily, our parents don’t force us to accept such myths. We had snacks and tea soon after the eclipse began around 11.25 a.m., as we have been in the ground since 10 a.m. to help people watch the event using telescopes and welder glasses,” Anusha said.
Explaining the natural phenomenon of solar eclipse when moon’s shadow falls on a part of the earth while in alignment with the sun, Shukre said he had no clue about the origin of the superstitious belief that eating, coming out of house or doing anything good during the eclipse was bad.
“The eclipse phenomenon has been occurring since time immemorial. There are at least two solar eclipses in a year on the earth. This apart, seven more eclipses, which are a mix of solar and lunar, take place in a year depending on the alignment of moon and earth with the sun in the centre,” Shurke pointed out.
The elliptical rotation of the earth around the sun and that of moon around earth also determine when and where the eclipses occur, which is a scientific event and has nothing to do with human beliefs.
In advanced countries like the US, people don’t even bother about the eclipses and do not link them to their lifestyle.
To disprove the belief as superstitious and irrational, Bharat Gyan Vijnan Samiti, a science forum, served ‘pongal’ (sweet rice) to people at a school ground in north Bangalore.
Similarly, a feisty lunch was arranged to devotees in a temple premises in the northern suburb of the city.
- Total lunar eclipse Dec 10 - Dec 06, 2011
- Star gazers catch glimpse of year's last lunar eclipse - Dec 11, 2011
- Total lunar eclipse on Saturday - Dec 07, 2011
- During longest eclipse, a Chand ka Langar to break taboo - Jun 16, 2011
- Bangalore's battle between astronomy and astrology over eclipse - Jul 20, 2009
- Excitement grips Bangalore as moon eclipses sun... almost - Jan 15, 2010
- Ignore superstitions, watch solar eclipse with proper gear - Jan 13, 2010
- From terrace, nightlong chase for century's darkest eclipse (With Images) - Jun 16, 2011
- Delhiites set to witness darkest lunar eclipse - Jun 15, 2011
- India to witness darkest lunar eclipse Wednesday - Jun 14, 2011
- Feast organised during solar eclipse in Orissa - Jan 15, 2010
- Scientists, astrologers differ on annual solar eclipse's impact on the country - Jan 14, 2010
- India to witness darkest lunar eclipse June 15 - Jun 03, 2011
- The Skygazers Are Waiting For The Rare View: Lunar Eclipse 2010 - Dec 20, 2010
- Partial solar eclipse in Delhi, but clouds play spoilsport - Jan 04, 2011
Tags: annular eclipse, bangalore, beehive, conservatives, distant sky, eatables, free lunch, gopal, jawaharlal nehru, jnp, kle, Lunar Eclipse, natural phenomenon, nehru planetarium, snacks, solar eclipse, sumptuous lunch, superstition, superstitions, telescopes
January 15th, 2010 at 11:31 pm
I am not sure if we should eat during an Eclipse, may be there is a scientific reason behind it which scientist have still not found. Dont think am an ignorant boy.I study in an IIT and i know quiet a bit about astrophysics. Even though there are many myths and superstitions that have got into our culture, most of our customs have a scientific reason behind them.
January 16th, 2010 at 12:10 am
This is not any news to make a big deal out of … everybody has their rights to follow what they believe. If u call this news then I m sorry to say that … this news is humbug. I dont believe in myths but u have no rights to mock or degrade the person who believes it …
January 16th, 2010 at 1:35 am
Today what we think and study may be bluff tomorrow but we know without today there will be no tomorrow, similarly without the past there is no present, our ancestors have brought us to a position where no other mammal has evolved, just because we are a little better does mean they were fools.
January 16th, 2010 at 1:43 am
also we can do a research on the babies born by conception on the solar eclipse day and look if any abnormalities, chromosomal linked, are increased. Even fetus below 6 wks can be included.
If i can i will do it next yr, this can give a paper in my name.
January 16th, 2010 at 11:11 am
Well said Lohit.