Bt Brinjal cleared without proper tests: Scientist
January 27th, 2010 - 8:18 pm ICT by IANSNew Delhi, Jan 27 (IANS) Leading molecular biologist Pushpa Bhargava Wednesday said India’s biotech regulatior had cleared genetically modified brinjal for commercial release without all the tests that should have been carried out.
“According to the international scientific community, some 30 tests should be done before any GMO (genetically modified organism) release. In the case of Bt Brinjal less than a dozen of these were conducted. Tests like protein-mix analysis, transprotein analysis and on metabolic processes weren’t done. Long term toxicity tests were also ignored,” Bhargava, a recipient of Padma Bhushan in 1986, alleged.
Bhargava, founder director of the Centre for Cellular and Molecular Biology (CCMB), was speaking on the sidelines of a seminar on Bt Brinjal at the Jawaharlal Nehru University here.
He is also the independent nominee of the Supreme Court to the Genetic Engineering Approval Committee (GEAC), the country’s biotech regulator.
In October last year, the GEAC approved the commercialisation of the genetically modified crop, which drew flak from various green NGOs and public health activists.
Environment Minister Jairam Ramesh is now holding public consultations on the issue and the approval is on hold. States that account for over 60 percent of the production of the vegetable have refused to allow Bt Brinjal.
Bhargava alleged that the head of GEAC’s expert committeee II Arjula Reddy had called him and told him that that he was under pressure from “the agriculture minister, GEAC and industry” to grant approval.
In a document that he sent the environment minister, Bhargava wrote: “Arjula made a totally confidential call to tell me that eight of the tests that I had said should be done on Bt Brinjal and with which he agreed had not been done…he was under tremendous pressre to clear the Bt Brinfal and had (received) calls from the agriculture minister, GEAC and industry.”
- Bt Brinjal will be single largest disaster, says scientist - Feb 01, 2010
- Explained: The ruckus over Bt Brinjal - Jan 30, 2010
- No pressure from PMO on Bt Brinjal: Jairam Ramesh - Jan 27, 2010
- India is sharply divided over introduction of Bt Brinjal - Feb 09, 2010
- No GM crop trials without states' consent: Jairam Ramesh - Mar 09, 2011
- Bt Brinjal: Greenpeace condemns government's double talk - Jan 22, 2010
- Andhra opposes Bt. Brinjal, wants its concerns heeded - Feb 06, 2010
- No decision on Bt Brinjal release before February (Roundup) - Oct 15, 2009
- Hunger strike against cultivation of Bt Brinjal in Kerala - Jan 30, 2010
- Bhargava calls for 15-year moratorium on GM crops in India - May 14, 2010
- Orissa won't allow genetically modified crop: minister - Oct 15, 2009
- Lift curbs on research in biotech crops: Scientists - Feb 28, 2012
- Baba Ramdev talks tough on BT brinjal issue - Jan 31, 2010
- No question of lifting moratorium on Bt Brinjal: Ramesh - Sep 27, 2010
- Uncommon furore over common brinjal - Feb 09, 2010
Tags: agriculture minister, bhargava, bhushan, cellular and molecular biology, commercialisation, environment minister, founder director, genetic engineering, gmo, health activists, jairam ramesh, jawaharlal nehru, jawaharlal nehru university, metabolic processes, molecular biologist, proper tests, protein mix, public consultations, sidelines, toxicity tests