Apple gets setback in patent warDecember 10th, 2011 - 1:55 pm ICT by IANS
San Francisco, Dec 10 (IANS) Apple Friday suffered a setback in its global patent war, as a German court ruled over its copyright infringement battle in favour of Motorola Mobility.
The German court ruled that Apple’s iPhone and iPad infringe a Motorola patent and issued an injunction banning the import of iPhones and 3G-capable iPads into Germany, reported Xinhua.
The dispute, one of Apple’s several patent lawsuits around the world, is over a Motorola patent essential to GPRS. Motorola has been negotiating with Apple over licensing terms and conditions since 2007, and it will continue its efforts to resolve its global patent dispute as soon as practicable, said Motorola Mobility in a statement Friday.
“We’re going to appeal the court’s ruling right away. Holiday shoppers in Germany should have no problem finding the iPad or iPhone they want,” an Apple spokesman told tech news site AllThingsD.
The ruling is against Apple’s European sales company and only impacts its products sold in Germany. The German court also ruled that Motorola is entitled to a damages award.
Apple can appeal the ruling to a higher court and request a stay of the injunction, according to a blog post of Florian Mueller, a US patent expert who has been closely following patent lawsuits in the mobile industry.
In August, Apple also filed a suit in Germany over the design of Motorola’s tablet Xoom, which runs Google’s Android system. But Apple did not make it clear whether it will seek to block the sales of Xoom in Europe.
Also Friday, Samsung won an appeal from the Australian High Court overturning a previous Apple victory that effectively banned Samsung from selling its Galaxy Tab in Australia.
Based on claims of infringing Apple’s patents, the Cupertino, California-based tech giant has been seeking court order to block Samsung’s Galaxy line of mobile devices around the world.
A German court issued an injunction in August, blocking Samsung from selling its Galaxy Tab 10.1 tablets across all European Union members, except for the Netherlands.
On Thursday, Apple said it will appeal a San Jose, California judge’s refusal to ban sales of Samsung 4G smartphones and Galaxy Tab 10.1 tablets in the US.
- Samsung seeks sales ban on iPhone 4S in Japan, Australia - Oct 17, 2011
- Apple wins battle to block Samsung tablets in Australia - Oct 13, 2011
- Samsung did not copy 'cool' Apple iPad: Court - Jul 10, 2012
- Apple awarded $1 bn in patent fight with Samsung - Aug 25, 2012
- Samsung has not infringed Apple's key patent: Tokyo court - Aug 31, 2012
- Apple wins slide to unlock case - Feb 17, 2012
- Motorola XOOM tablet launched in India - Jun 28, 2011
- Stanley Kubrick made the first iPad, claims Samsung - Aug 24, 2011
- Judge rules that Apple's iPad is cooler than Samsung's Galaxy tablet - Jul 11, 2012
- Apple sues Samsung over Galaxy phones, tablets - Apr 19, 2011
- Motorola hit with trademark suit just before Xoom launch - Feb 25, 2011
- Samsung seeks sales ban on iPhone 4S in France, Italy - Oct 05, 2011
- Motorola Zooms Ahead In Tablet Race With Xoom! - Jan 06, 2011
- Samsung Galaxy S3 sales top 20 mn - Sep 06, 2012
- World's leading electronics fair opens in Berlin - Sep 04, 2011
Tags: copyright infringement, cupertino california, damages award, galaxy line, german court, global patent, google, gprs motorola, holiday shoppers, ipads, iphone, iphones, mobile industry, patent dispute, patent expert, patent lawsuits, patent war, us patent, xinhua, xoom