Modi’s 2002 cannot be washed away — so soonSeptember 18th, 2011 - 5:48 pm ICT by IANS
New Delhi, Sep 18 (IANS) He may have prime ministerial ambitions but Gujarat Chief Minister Narendra Modi’s 2002 riots ghost will not leave him soon, say political analysts and critics.
On Sunday, the second day of his three-day hunger strike aimed at cementing communal relations in the state, criticism of Modi’s past record continued, both in and outside the state.
B.R.P. Bhaskar, a Kerala-based political analyst, thinks Modi’s fast has come too late and creates suspicion.
“He will have to prove the genuineness of his new proclamations as he has already destroyed the social fabric of the state,” Bhaskar told IANS over telephone.
Modi, blamed for the biased handling of the 2002 Gujarat communal riots, launched his ’sadbhavana’ (goodwill) fast from a university hall Saturday — as he turned 61.
Mridula Mukherjee, a professor with Delhi’s Jawaharlal Nehru University, calls the fast a “farce”.
“The exercise is manipulative and the prayer for togetherness mentioned in his ’sadbhavana’ statement betrays his political ambitions.”
Mukherjee said scenes of Muslims wearing skull caps and in burqa greeting Modi at the fast venue did not mean much.
“Nothing has changed on the ground in Gujarat - be it the rightwing textbooks or the atmosphere of discrimination,” she added.
Congress spokesman Rashid Alvi spoke on similar lines.
He said “a mere fast cannot wash away (Modi’s) tainted past, packed with serious commissions and omissions”.
“It will carry no conviction with any secular person in the country,” Alvi told IANS.
The BJP thinks differently.
“The past week vindicated Modi and the BJP on many fronts,” BJP spokesperson Nirmala Sitharaman told IANS, referring to the Supreme Court ordering a trial court to hear a case alleging the chief minister’s complicity in the Gulberg housing society killings in 2002 - a move that was interpreted in completely different ways by the party and its rivals.
But Sitharaman thinks “it’s premature” to discuss the prime ministerial candidature of Modi or to even link it with the fast.
She quoted a US Congressional Research Service report as praising Modi’s governance and achievements.
Bhaskar feels it is a hype that Modi will emerge at the national level one day. “Even the US report admits he is popular only in Gujarat.”
- Case against Modi should be closed: BJP - Feb 11, 2012
- Will Modi be BJP's prime ministerial candidate? - May 27, 2012
- Narendra Modi to sit on fast - Sep 13, 2011
- Modi's fast: BJP top brass to attend; Modi condemns communalism - Sep 17, 2011
- Modi and Vaghela on fast track politics in Gujarat - Sep 16, 2011
- Despite exoneration, Narendra Modi cannot play national role (Comment) - Apr 14, 2012
- No clean chit to Modi: Congress - Sep 12, 2011
- Despite grand show, few takers for Modi as future PM - Sep 19, 2011
- Modi ends fast on upbeat note, but divisions remain (Roundup) - Sep 19, 2011
- Modi's fast biggest political stunt of the decade: Congress - Sep 21, 2011
- Modi's absence, talk of PM candidate, cloud BJP meet (Roundup) - Sep 30, 2011
- Court verdict a vindication, says BJP; Congress says no clean chit to Modi (Roundup) - Sep 13, 2011
- Modi's fast unconstitutional: Madhya Pradesh JD-U - Sep 18, 2011
- Verdict victory for Modi, claims BJP - Sep 12, 2011
- Stop vilification campaign against Modi: BJP - Apr 10, 2012
Tags: alvi, bjp, chief minister, communal relations, communal riots, congress spokesman, genuineness, gujarat, housing society, hunger strike, jawaharlal nehru, jawaharlal nehru university, mridula mukherjee, narendra modi, political ambitions, political analyst, political analysts, proclamations, skull caps, social fabric