Lokpal bill: Key differences between government, civil societyAugust 4th, 2011 - 9:35 pm ICT by IANS
New Delhi, Aug 4 (IANS) The anti-graft Lokpal bill was introduced in parliament Thursday amid vehement protests from the opposition. Civil society activists, led by Gandhian Anna Hazare, too criticised the government draft. Here are the key points of disagreement between the government and the civil society on the bill:
Prime Minister: The civil society wants the prime minister to be under the Lokpal’s ambit. The government has kept the prime minister out of the Lokpal’s purview, but he/she can be probed after demitting office. Opposition parties too are opposed to keeping the prime minister out of the Lokpal’s ambit.
Higher judiciary: The civil society wants the Lokpal to have powers to probe the higher judiciary, including judges of the Supreme Court. The government has kept the higher judiciary out.
MPs: The government has excluded the acts of MPs inside parliament and in parliamentary committees outside the Lokpal’s purview, which the civil society has opposed.
Lower bureaucracy: According to the government draft, only officers of joint secretary level and above are covered under the Lokpal. The civil society wants the entire bureaucracy to come within the Lokpal’s purview.
CBI and CVC: The government has struck down civil society’s proposal to merge the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) and Central Vigilance Commission (CVC) with the Lokpal.
Punishment: The civil society has proposed minimum one year rigorous imprisonment and maximum of life imprisonment for the corrupt. The government has capped the maximum punishment at 10 years.
Lokayukta: The civil society wants the appointment of Lokayuktas, the ombudsmen in states, to be overseen by the Lokpal, which the government has struck down.
- Lokpal: Points of contention - Jun 21, 2011
- Aamir is backing Jan Lokpal bill: Team Anna - Jul 20, 2011
- Government vs Team Anna - demands on Lokpal - Dec 27, 2011
- Lokpal bill: Who stands where - Dec 22, 2011
- Meeting on Lokpal ends amid major differences (Second Lead) - May 31, 2011
- Confrontation looms as Lokpal report is tabled (Roundup) - Dec 09, 2011
- Thousands join as Hazare begins indefinite fast (Lead) - Apr 05, 2011
- This Lokpal bill is useless, says Bhushan - Aug 04, 2011
- Team Anna, government agree to disagree on Lokpal (Lead) - Jun 21, 2011
- Cabinet clears draft Lokpal bill; angry Team Anna protests (Second Lead) - Jul 28, 2011
- Hazare meets Sonia, parties differ on PM under Lokpal (Roundup) - Jul 02, 2011
- Civil society upset over 'sarkari' Lokpal (Lead) - Jul 28, 2011
- Mukherjee seeks views on Lokpal bill; government says talks on right path (Lead) - May 31, 2011
- Some Jan Lokpal bill provisions are impractical: Pranab - Aug 26, 2011
- Team Anna unhappy over reports of proposed Lokpal bill - Nov 21, 2011
Tags: anti graft, bureaucracy, cbi, central bureau of investigation, central vigilance commission, civil society activists, disagreement, gandhian, judiciary, life imprisonment, maximum of life, maximum punishment, New Delhi, ombudsmen, opposition parties, parliamentary committees, prime minister, purview, rigorous imprisonment, vehement protests