Congress trying to make Sanjay Gandhi scapegoat for Emergency misdeeds: AdvaniJanuary 2nd, 2011 - 4:10 pm ICT by IANS
New Delhi, Jan 2 (IANS) Senior Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) leader L.K. Advani Sunday charged the Congress with trying to make the late Sanjay Gandhi a scapegoat for all the “misdeeds” during the the Emergency and said its promulgation was “an unforgivble crime against democracy”.In the latest post “Emergency of 1975 akin to Nazi rule” on his blog, Advani said that the book published by the Congress, “Congress and the Making of the Indian Nation,” carries just two curt paragraphs to tell the country what happened during the Emergency of 1975-77 but has two pages about factors leading to the Emergency, including Jayaprakash Narayan’s “extra-constitutional and undemocratic movement” and the Allahabad High Court’s verdict charging former prime minister Indira Gandhi with violating the election law to win her seat and invalidating her election.
Referring to the paragraph mentioning Sanjay Gandhi, Indira Gandhi’s son, Advani said it is “a ridiculous attempt to make Sanjay Gandhi a scapegoat for all the misdeeds the country had to suffer during the Emergency”.
“In the last sixty years, whenever the executive has found a judicial verdict unpalatable, its reaction has been to have the verdict undone by mobilizing legislative support for the executive’s view point. In 1975 also this was sought to be done by amending the law in respect of electoral corruption.
“But Mrs. Gandhi did not stop there. Without consulting her cabinet, or even her law minister and home minister, she made president Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed invoke Article 352 to put democracy under indefinite suspension,” Advani wrote.
He added: “The Congress party publication indicates that the party regrets only the excesses’ committed during the Emergency, because Sanjay Gandhi promoted worthwhile causes such as slum-clearance, anti-dowry measures, and literacy, but in an arbitrary and authoritarian manner.”
Advani said he holds that “promulgation of the Emergency itself was an unforgivable crime against democracy and that the constitution makers had never ever conceived that any prime minister of independent India would so grossly abuse Article 352 of the Constitution.”
The BJP leader said almost all MISA (Maitenance of Internal Security Act) detenues had filed habeas corpus petitions in their respective state high courts and at all places and almost all the courts rejected the government’s objection.
“The diary I used to maintain while I was in prison records the names of 19 judges who were transferred to other high courts because they had decided against the government!”
He also noted that pronouncing majority judgement in the appeal, the Supreme Court bench comprising of chief justice A.N. Ray, justices H.R. Khanna, M.H. Beg, Y.V. Chandrachud and P.N. Bhagwati (Khanna dissenting ) declared: “In view of the presidential order dated 27 June, 1975 no person has any locus standi to move any writ petition under Article 226 before a high court for habeas corpus. The appeals are accepted. The judgements of the high courts are set aside.”
Advani also recalled that Khanna, in his dissenting judment, observed: “…Supposing a law is made that in the matter of the protection of life and liberty, the administrative officers would not be governed by any law and that it would be permissible for them to deprive a person of life and liberty without any authority of law. In one sense, it might in that event be argued that even if lives of hundreds of persons are taken capriciously and maliciously without the authority of law, it is enforcement of the above enacted law. Thus, in a purely formal sense, any system or norm based on a hierarchy of orders, even the organised mass murders of Nazi regime, can qualify as law.”
Advani said that in its editorial after justice Khanna delivered his landmark judgement, the New York Times wrote April 30, 1976: “If India ever finds its way back to the freedom and democracy that were proud hallmarks of its first 18 years as an independent nation, someone will surely erect a monument to Justice H.R. Khanna of the Supreme Court.”
- Congress making Sanjay scapegoat for Emergency misdeeds: Advani (Lead) - Jan 02, 2011
- Emergency a sad period in Indian history: Kuldip Nayar (June 25 marks 35th anniversary of Emergency) - Jun 25, 2010
- Won't make public records on emergency: President's secretariat - Aug 31, 2010
- Akhilesh offers sops for prisoners of emergency - May 01, 2012
- Court declines Muslim man's plea for custody of son - Jun 17, 2011
- No need to make emergency documents public: Court - Jul 12, 2011
- On Vodafone ruling, father-son Bhushans don't see eye to eye - Mar 23, 2012
- Karnataka battle: NDA leaders meet PM; Yeddyurappa, MLAs to meet president (Roundup) - May 16, 2011
- BJP MP praises MISA - Dec 02, 2009
- Apex court rejects plea on election symbols (Lead) - Apr 18, 2012
- Court allows Adani to go to Goa for CBI questioning - Mar 30, 2010
- After Musharraf's exit, Zardari 'new face of disaster for Pak': Nisar - Mar 14, 2011
- NGO wants SC to reject presidential reference in 2G case (Lead) - Jul 10, 2012
- Debate needed on Ramlila crackdown judgment: Advani - Mar 04, 2012
- Sonia Gandhi appeals for peace following Ayodhya verdict - Sep 29, 2010
Tags: allahabad high court, bharatiya janata party, bjp leader, congress party, electoral corruption, former prime minister, gandhi indira, home minister, indefinite suspension, indira gandhi, jayaprakash narayan, l k advani, law minister, legislative support, mrs gandhi, nazi rule, prime minister indira, sanjay gandhi, slum clearance, worthwhile causes