Asian media’s power to expose graft not fully unleashed: UNDPJune 12th, 2008 - 6:52 pm ICT by IANS
New Delhi, June 12 (IANS) Strong media can boost anti-corruption efforts in Asia and the Pacific but serious constraints still impede the full power of the press to report on corruption, the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) reported Thursday. Media represents a key ingredient to keep governments and private businesses honest, UNDP said in its newly launched Asia-Pacific Human Development report “Tackling Corruption, Transforming Lives”.
The media across Asia and the Pacific faces two main constraints - from government censorship that may obscure corruption, and from market pressures to serve the interests of wealthy individuals who also may be corrupt, the report said.
These can also be compounded by lack of investigative skills, all of which impede human development, particularly for the poor, the report noted.
“Tackling corruption is not a job for governments alone,” said Omar Noman, chief of policies and programmes at the UNDP regional centre in Colombo, at the Thursday launch of the report in Jakarta.
“The media and individual citizens all need to stay alert, demanding the highest ethical standards and resolving to reject corruption wherever it appears,” he said.
Empowering the media, enacting laws on the right to information and using information technology and e-governance to make governments more transparent can prevent as well as expose corruption across the region, the report advised.
Disclosures on the Internet are becoming more widespread, such as the case of an independent journalist in China who exposed a local official who stole $400,000, the report noted.
In India, the wife of one whistleblower built a website to make his case known to the world. “In the YouTube era, it is harder to kill a man who has a bit of Internet renown,” the report added.
Overall, the extent of press freedom in the Asia-Pacific region remains low. An indication can be gathered from the ratings of independent organisations such as Reporters Without Borders, an NGO that compiles an annual index of press freedom based on 50 criteria.
The 2007 index rated 169 countries, of which the top 10 were all European. Six Asia-Pacific countries ranked among the bottom 10.
However, even a free press is not enough to ensure good governance and reduce corruption, the report cautioned.
“What these countries need in addition are clean and efficient systems of justice that will follow up on widely-reported allegations,” the report said.
Nevertheless it would be wrong to say that media in these countries has been completely ineffective. In many countries with the most open media, including India, Philippines and Indonesia, media coverage has helped to create public pressure for reform, even if this has been slow to materialize.
It could also be argued that without a free press, the situation in these countries would have been far worse, the report added.
Responsible and ethical journalists are crucial, the report said. At the same time, freedom must be balanced with responsibility to preserve the credibility of the media.
For example, one survey cited in the report found that 70 percent of Indonesian journalists in East Java and 97 percent of those in Jakarta were taking payments from their news sources.
Establishment of independent media watch groups and press councils, thus, is critical, the report maintains.
The press is most effective where there is a plurality of media representing diverse views and ownership patterns, and operating in a competitive market. A survey of 28 Asia-Pacific countries found that most had both private- and government-owned media; however, in East Asia and the Pacific roughly one-third of countries reported only government-owned newspapers.
A powerful way to control corruption is to enact progressive laws on the right to information (RTI), such as has been done in India, the report says.
“Public officials need to be engaged and convinced about the value of right to information - and develop the ability to deal with requests promptly and appropriately,” said Anuradha Rajivan, head of UNDP’s Regional Human Development Report Unit.
“At the same time, the media and other parts of civil society must learn how to use right-to-information systems responsibly,” she added.
Community radio stations or broadcast outlets run by non-profit groups can act as a means for keeping corruption in check, especially in poor or remote areas, the report said.
For example, community radio stations in Nepal are raising awareness with the NGO Pro Public through more than 5,500 Good Governance Radio Clubs with 53,000 members.
Fem’Link, an NGO in Fiji, broadcasts a regular series of community discussions among women using mobile radio and television equipment that can be carried from village to village; corruption is a recurring theme because it hits women particularly hard, the report pointed out.
In Papua New Guinea, a hotline allows members of the public to report suspected cases of corruption directly to the media.
Tags: asia pacific region, asian media, e governance, government censorship, independent journalist, investigative skills, launch, market pressures, omar noman, orga, press freedom, private businesses, regional centre, renown, transforming lives, undp, united nations development, united nations development programme, using information technology, wealthy individuals