Apex court puts off order on Amar Singh, Jaya Prada plea (Lead)November 10th, 2010 - 9:43 pm ICT by IANS
New Delhi, Nov 10 (IANS) The Supreme Court Wednesday reserved its order on a petition by Rajya Sabha member Amar Singh and actress-turned-MP Jaya Prada pleading that they should not attract disqualification under the anti-defection law if they defy the Samajwadi Party’s whip after their expulsion.
However, the apex court bench of Justice Altamas Kabir and Justice Cyriac Joseph indicated that it would refer the matter to a larger bench and pass an order Monday (Nov 15).
The court said that it would also frame the issues to be addressed by the larger bench.
The court hinted at referring the matter of the larger bench when Attorney General G. Vahanvati agreed to a suggestion in this regard by the court.
Both Amar Singh and Jaya Pradha were expelled from the party for their alleged anti-party activities Feb 2. Amar Singh is a member of the Rajya Sabha and Jaya Pradha is a member of the Lok Sabha.
After their expulsion from the party, both of them have been declared as unattached parliamentarians.
Under the existing provisions of the anti-defection law both of them would forfeit their membership of the parliament if they defy the Samajwadi Party’s whip or join any other party.
The petitioners said that the application of the provisions of the anti-defection law in respect of them was violative of the basic structure of constitution.
Appearing for Amar Singh, senior counsel Harish Salve said that under the existing provisions of anti-defection law in the 10th schedule of the constitution only those MPs would attract disqualification who voluntarily give up the membership of the party they belong to or defy the whip of the party at the time of voting in the house.
He said that there could not be a situation where the petitioners (Amar Singh and Jaya Prada) have to discharge all the duties towards the party without any right. He said that such a proposition goes too far to suppress the right to free speech.
When senior counsel K.K. Venugopal appearing for Jaya Prada said that they were accountable not only to the party but also to their electorate in the constituency, the court pointed out that “you were elected on the policy and programme of the party” you represented during the election.
At this Venugopal said: “I am also voted for my performance.”
- Apex court gives relief to Amar Singh, Jaya Prada (Lead) - Nov 15, 2010
- Amar Singh, Jayaprada's plea hearing adjourned to Nov 9 - Oct 25, 2010
- Jaya Prada, Amar Singh's plea on anti-defection law adjourned - Oct 25, 2010
- Apex court reserves order on Amar Singh, Jaya Prada plea - Nov 10, 2010
- Court quashes Odisha speaker's ruling on BJP legislator - Jun 18, 2012
- SP expels Amar Singh and 'close compatriot' Jaya Prada - Feb 02, 2010
- Amar Singh's bail a Diwali gift: Jaya Prada - Oct 24, 2011
- Defector BSP legislator disqualified - Oct 17, 2011
- NCP threatens to disqualify Meghalaya legislators - Aug 26, 2012
- Jaya Prada takes on Azam Khan - Mar 03, 2012
- Rampur stuns Jaya Prada - Mar 06, 2012
- From stars to Tihar, Amar Singh's fall from grace - Sep 06, 2011
- Disqualified Karnataka legislators' case adjourned to Tuesday (Lead) - Oct 11, 2010
- NCP seeks disqualification of four Odisha legislators - Jul 10, 2012
- Karnataka High Court to resume hearing on rebel BJP MLAs tomorrow - Oct 20, 2010
Tags: amar singh, apex, apex court, court bench, defection, expulsion from, feb 2, free speech, jaya prada, jaya pradha, kabir, Lok Sabha, parliamentarians, petitioners, rajya sabha, sabha member, salve, Samajwadi Party, senior counsel, whip