Societies use punishment as a tool to enforce norms in large populations
March 19th, 2010 - 2:23 pm ICT by ANI ( Leave a comment )Washington, Mar 19 (ANI): A society with a large number of people uses punishment to enforce norms, while the same does not hold true for societies with lower population, where everybody knows each other, claims a study.
The new study co-authored by University of California, Davis, anthropologist Richard McElreath suggests that the cooperative nature of each society is at least partly dependent upon historical forces - such as religious beliefs and the growth of market transactions.
The study also found the extent to which a society uses punishment to enforce norms increases and decreases with the number of people in the society.
“It is likely that small and large communities regulate cooperation - mutual defense, conservation, etc. - in different ways, because different mechanisms of monitoring and enforcement of norms work better at different scales of society,” explained McElreath.
“A small town in Kansas, for example, can likely rely upon reputation and the fact that everyone knows everyone else, while the residents of New York City need some mechanism, like punishment, that can work in the absence of reliable reputations,” he added.
The researchers probed why communities often cooperate in diverse ways, from mutual defense to conservation.
People engage in such mutually beneficial acts even though they may be individually costly.
The researchers used behavioural experiments administered across 15 diverse populations, and sought to measure the influence of three different mechanisms - punishment, market integration and religious beliefs - that might maintain cooperation within societies.
Market integration is the extent to which individuals use anonymous, rule-governed transactions to buy and sell goods.
The researchers found that overt punishment, religious beliefs that can act as a form of psychological punishment and market integration each were correlated with fairness in the experiments.
The study has been published in Science magazine. (ANI)
- "Silver spoon" effect found in world's most ancient economies - Oct 30, 2009
- Sticking to values activates 'ethics' part of brain - Jan 23, 2012
- Nevada Religious Freedom & Unity Day opened with Hindu invocation - Sep 21, 2010
- Bhopal like hazards growing in urban centres, warn activists - Dec 03, 2011
- Falling church attendance? Blame it on higher life expectancy! - Apr 11, 2011
- Free market, religions fostered fairplay in society: Study - Mar 22, 2010
- Power and corruption 'maintain cooperation in society' - Dec 15, 2010
- Chidambaram releases video featuring IAS topper from Kashmir - Nov 25, 2010
- Does corruption, power fuel cooperation in society? - Dec 15, 2010
- Text of President Barack Obama's address to India's parliament - Nov 08, 2010
- Hindus urge Germany to be more open to 'other religions' and 'outsiders' - Dec 31, 2010
- How a leader is chosen impacts whether others will follow - Dec 03, 2010
- Do plants pay a price for evolving with complex defense mechanisms? - Jan 29, 2011
- Legal order must constantly adapt itself to change: Manmohan Singh - Feb 06, 2011
- Economic dialogue will help develop mutual trust: Wen Jiabao - Sep 27, 2011
Tags: anthropologist, cooperation, cooperative nature, decreases, different ways, extent, fairness, market integration, market transactions, mechanisms, new york city, norms, populations, psychological punishment, religious beliefs, reputation, reputations, scales, university of california, university of california davis