SC asks Ambanis to settle gas row through ’suitable arrangement’
October 21st, 2009 - 7:41 pm ICT by ANI ( Leave a comment )New Delhi, Oct. 21 (ANI): The Supreme Court on Wednesday asked why the Ambani brothers cannot settle their gas supply row through a “suitable arrangement.”
During a hearing of the dispute over supply of gas by RIL to RNRL at 2.34 dollars per mmBtu, the bench headed by Chief Justice K G Balakrishnan said the two parties could arrive at a “suitable arrangement” through arbitration.
The case between Reliance Industries, headed by Mukesh, and the Reliance Natural Resources Ltd, led by Anil, is over a deal to sell gas from the Krishna Basin Reserve to the Reliance Natural Resource Limited (RNRL) at below-market rates as per a family settlement.
RIL headed by Mukesh, told the court that it considered the government’s gas utilisation and pricing policy as the “suitable arrangement.”
RIL counsel Harish Salve also opposed Reliance Natural Resources Ltd’s plea for dismissing RIL’s petition, saying only his client’s creditors or members of the Board can challenge maintainability of the petition.
Salve said RNRL was a third party and hence, cannot seek dismissal of RIL’s plea.
RNRL has also separately challenged the government’s petition in the dispute.
Just ten days ago, Anil made a surprise truce offer to resolve the dispute amicably. But with Mukesh rejecting Anil’s olive branch, the action has now moved to the Supreme Court.
In a statement on October 11, Anil said all disagreements could be resolved within weeks, but RIL questioned the sincerity of the offer made “through the public domain” and said Anil could have easily contacted his elder brother directly.
RIL also asked Anil to demonstrate the bonafide of his intentions behind the latest overture, adding it welcomes this positive indicator and will not be found wanting in responding to them constructively.
The latest tussle between the feuding brothers, which stems from the 2005 break-up of the Reliance empire built by their father, has raised concerns it could discourage investment in the sector as India scrambles to shore up its energy security.
The Government had earlier made a petition to intervene in the case, arguing that the gas is ’state property’ and that the private agreement between the Ambanis over the gas is not valid. (ANI)
- Ambani family pact not binding on RIL: Counsel - Nov 11, 2009
- Supreme Court to continue Ambanis gas row hearing today - Oct 21, 2009
- Reliance owners fighting like persons heading two countries: SC - Oct 20, 2009
- Supreme Court to hear Ambanis gas row today - Oct 20, 2009
- 'Anil Ambani entitled to earlier rights in RIL if de-merger fails' (Lead) - Nov 25, 2009
- Anil Ambani firm wins legal tussle over gas supply (Lead) - Jun 15, 2009
- KG Basin row: SC says government is owner of gas - May 07, 2010
- Ambani family pact not binding on RIL: Counsel (Lead) - Nov 11, 2009
- KG basin gas row: SC to deliver verdict today - May 07, 2010
- RNRL wins legal tussle over gas supply - Jun 15, 2009
- Anil Ambani makes a surprise appearance at Supreme Court - Nov 24, 2009
- Supreme Court reserves verdict in Reliance gas dispute - Dec 18, 2009
- Apex court reserves verdict on Krishna-Godavari gas row (Lead) - Dec 18, 2009
- Murli Deora welcomes Supreme Court's verdict on Krishna Godavari Basin Gas dispute - May 07, 2010
- Anil Ambani marks presence in Supreme Court - Nov 24, 2009
Tags: ambani brothers, basin reserve, bonafide, chief justice, disagreements, elder brother, family settlement, gas utilisation, k g balakrishnan, krishna, mukesh, natural resource, october 11, olive branch, reliance industries, ril, rnrl, sincerity, suitable arrangement, tussle