Professor Higgs in Big Bang collision with Stephen Hawking!September 11th, 2008 - 1:12 pm ICT by ANI
London, September 11 (ANI): Among the celebrations of the worlds greatest scientific experiment the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) going underway, Professor Peter Higgs has launched a withering attack on Professor Stephen Hawking, saying his work was not good enough.
According to a report in the Times, Higgs, the scientist who gave his name to the Higgs boson, the particle at the centre of the LHC experiment, dismissed Hawkings views on the 2.6 billion pounds project, and said that no other particle physicist would view his approach as correct.
Professor Higgs, who faced a press conference in Edinburgh yesterday, was reacting to an interview in which Professor Hawking jokingly suggested that it would be more exciting if the experiment at CERN on the Franco-Swiss border did not find the God particle it has been set up to identify.
That will show something is wrong, and we will need to think again, Hawking had said.
Professor Hawking once placed a 100 dollar bet that the particle does not exist and continues to argue that there are more interesting outcomes to be drawn from the LHC than the discovery of the Higgs boson.
Professor Higgs, who first postulated the existence of the particle 44 years ago, reacted with visible irritation.
I have to confess I havent read the paper in which Stephen Hawking makes this claim, he said. But I have read one he wrote, which I think is the basis for the kind of calculation he does. And frankly I dont think the way he does it is good enough, he added.
According to Higgs, My understanding is he puts together theories in particle physics with gravity in a way which no theoretical particle physicist would believe is the correct theory.
From a particle physics, quantum theory point of view, you have to put a lot more than just gravity into the theory to have a consistent theory and I dont think Stephen has done that. I am very doubtful about his calculations, he added.
Other members of the panel moved swiftly to cut off the discussion, suggesting that he had taken Professor Hawkings views out of context.
But, it was clear that Professor Higgs did not rate his rivals view that the LHC would be more likely to reveal a number of partner particles than the boson.
Both men are contenders for the Nobel prize depending on the outcome of the experiment and their spat is likely to send shockwaves through the scientific Establishment. (ANI)
- God Particle's discovery 'biggest leap in physics' (Roundup) - Jul 05, 2012
- Indian scientists dismiss reports on 'god particle' - May 01, 2011
- Ironical that Bose did not get Nobel Prize: CERN chief (Interview) - Sep 03, 2012
- Can Hadron Collider be world's first time machine? - Mar 17, 2011
- Has the 'Big Bang' machine detected the elusive 'God particle'? - Apr 23, 2011
- Could Large Hadron Collider be world's first time machine? - Mar 16, 2011
- Scientists claim discovery of Higgs boson-like particle (Lead) - Jul 05, 2012
- 'God particle' mystery to be solved by 2012 - May 18, 2011
- Scientists claim Large Hadron Collider could unlock secret of time travel - Mar 21, 2011
- Saha Institute to take up boson naming case with CERN - Sep 01, 2012
- Possible discovery of new sub-atomic particle could upset rules of physics - Apr 18, 2011
- After particle discovery, spotlight on Satyendra Nath Bose - Jul 05, 2012
- Scientists trash reports of God particle discovery - Jul 16, 2010
- Large Hadron Colliders discovery of God particle would be no big deal, says scientist - Sep 12, 2008
- Post Higgs, Cern turns spotlight on dark matter - Jul 08, 2012
Tags: bet, big bang, cern, consistent theory, correct theory, god particle, gravity, higgs boson, large hadron collider, lhc experiment, particle physics, peter higgs, professor peter, professor stephen, quantum theory, scientific experiment, stephen hawking, swiss border, theoretical particle physicist, theory point