Plea against Ketan Desai’s university post rejected (Lead)
December 22nd, 2010 - 11:38 pm ICT by IANSAhmedabad/New Delhi, Dec 22 (IANS) The Gujarat High Court Wednesday rejected a public interest litigation (PIL) against the election of tainted former Medical Council of India (MCI) chief Ketan Desai to the Gujarat University senate.The bench comprising Chief Justice S.J. Mukhopadhaya and Justice Akil Kureshi also imposed a cost of Rs.10,000 on the petitioner.
The court, which stopped short of slapping a cost of $10,000, directed the petitioner to pay the money to the Indian Red Cross Society.
The judges said the petition lacked merit and did not have any public interest. They said the petitioner could not clarify his interest and intention in the petition.
“I am deeply shocked that the court dismissed our PIL that challenged the election of Desai,” said Kunal Saha who heads the People for Better Treatment (PBT), a doctors’ group which filed the petition.
The PIL was filed against the election of Desai to the senate against a seat reserved for a medical graduate.
The group in its petition said that Desai was arrested on graft charges and his medical degree was suspended by the MCI.
Desai was arrested in April this year for allegedly taking Rs.2 crore bribe from a Punjab-based medical college. The MCI suspended his medical licence in October.
“The court imposed a penalty of Rs.10,000 on the ground that there was no public interest involved in the petition even without letting my attorney argue,” Saha said.
“The court said that I cannot file the PIL as I am a non-resident Indian (NRI). The petition was filed by the PBT and similar petitions from us have earlier been heard by the Supreme Court,” he said.
The high court said it was unclear as to how Saha was concerned about public interest of Indians when he was settled in Ohio in the US.
Saha added that the doctors’ group would now approach the apex court.
The high court earlier said that Desai was an accused in a case but not proved guilty so far. The court said the law provided for a person guilty of scandalous behaviour to be suspended.
“Show us any provision that bars a medical graduate from contesting a senate election,” asked the court.
- Gujarat court rejects plea against Ketan Desai - Dec 22, 2010
- After court rap, doctor's group unsure about PIL on Ketan Desai - Dec 21, 2010
- Ketan Desai's election to Gujarat University senate challenged - Mar 28, 2011
- Pay in dollars if plea is found frivolous, court tells NRI - Dec 20, 2010
- Court reserves order on plea against Ketan Desai - Dec 15, 2010
- Court questions plea against Ketan Desai - Dec 13, 2010
- Court bench refuses to take up Ketan Desai PIL - Dec 02, 2010
- Doctors group protests Desai's election to Gujarat University senate - Nov 20, 2010
- Ketan Desai's election to university body challenged - Nov 29, 2010
- High court imposes fine for frivolous PIL - Apr 15, 2011
- After medical license, Desai may lose FRCS title - Oct 30, 2010
- MCI suspends Ketan Desai's medical licence - Oct 10, 2010
- 'Tainted Ketan Desai off to Canada meet soon' - Oct 09, 2010
- Court questions CBI over Ketan Desai's bail plea (Lead) - May 11, 2010
- Plea questioning reliability of voting machines dismissed - Oct 19, 2010
Tags: akil, apex court, doctors group, graft charges, gujarat high court, gujarat university, indian red cross society, ketan desai, kureshi, mci chief, medical council of india, medical council of india mci, medical degree, medical graduate, medical licence, public interest litigation, red cross society, s university, saha, university senate