Fate of Obama’s healthcare law hangs in balanceMarch 29th, 2012 - 11:47 am ICT by IANS
B0y Arun Kumar
Washington, March 29 (IANS) The fate of President Barack Obama’s signature federal healthcare overhaul hangs in balance with the US Supreme Court wrapping up a historic hearing with an apparent ideological divide among conservative and liberal judges.
In six hours of hearings spread over three days, the Supreme Court heard arguments on one of the most controversial issues of the day, touching on legal concepts involving federal and state powers, individual rights and legislative intent.
As many as 26 opposition Republican ruled states have challenged Obama’s signature legislation that requires most Americans to have health coverage as part of a systemic overhaul intended to lower costs as he seeks re-election in November.
On the final day of hearing on legal challenges to the 2010 Affordable Care Act Wednesday, the nine justices tackled the question of what would happen if they ruled that the heart of the law, the individual mandate that requires people to get health coverage or pay a fine, was unconstitutional.
The Supreme Court ruling is expected in late June in the thick of the election campaign. An adverse judgement would be a setback for Obama, but White House spokesperson Josh Earnest said the Obama administration remained confident the healthcare law is constitutional.
Anyone who tries to predict the outcome of the case based on the questions justices asked during this week’s arguments “is not a very good student of the Supreme Court”, Earnest told reporters.
Justice Department lawyers faced similar tough questions from conservative judges in lower courts that later upheld the law “in at least a couple of these cases”, he said.
However, some of the attorneys general of states opposing the healthcare law said the three days of arguments showed the justices had serious concerns about the law.
(Arun Kumar can be contacted at firstname.lastname@example.org)
- US Supreme Court hears challenge to 'Obamacare' - Mar 27, 2012
- US healthcare verdict gives Obama huge win - Jun 29, 2012
- US court tosses out key parts of Obama's healthcare reform - Aug 13, 2011
- US top court upholds Obama's signature healthcare law - Jun 28, 2012
- South Asians fear racial profiling over US court ruling - Jun 26, 2012
- US apex court sides with Obama on immigration law - Jun 25, 2012
- Gujarat Lokayukta's appointment upheld by high court (Third lead) - Jan 18, 2012
- US state faces doctor, nurse shortages - Jul 02, 2012
- Gujarat Lokayukta's appointment upheld by high court (Second lead) - Jan 18, 2012
- South Asians seek rejection of tough US immigration law - Apr 26, 2012
- US judge declares Obama administration's health care overhaul as 'unconstitutional' - Feb 01, 2011
- Obama names Indian-American to communications body - Nov 01, 2011
- 11 vacancies of judges in Supreme Court by next year - Sep 05, 2011
- Respect judicial independence, Kapadia tells government. - Aug 15, 2012
- Huge case backlog before Supreme Court's constitution bench - Jun 15, 2011
Tags: affordable care, arun kumar, barack obama, care act, conservative judges, controversial issues, election campaign, health coverage, healthcare law, individual rights, justice department lawyers, legal challenges, legislative intent, liberal judges, serious concerns, signature legislation, supreme court ruling, tough questions, us supreme court, white house spokesperson