Urine LAM-ELISA not effective as independent diagnostic test for pulmonary TB
August 28th, 2009 - 2:40 pm ICT by ANI ( Leave a comment )Washington, August 28 (ANI): A trial of the new diagnostic urine LAM-ELISA has indicated that it may not be useful as an independent diagnostic test for pulmonary tuberculosis (TB).
Detailed in the open access journal BMC Infectious Diseases, the results suggest that it was only capable of identifying 50.7 per cent of TB cases.
Klaus Reither led a team of researchers from the Ludwig-Maximilians-University of Munich, Germany, the University College London, UK, and the NIMR-Mbeya Medical Research Programme, Tanzania, who tested LAM-ELISA in 291 Tanzanian patients suspected of having TB.
He said: “Only 35 out of 69 pulmonary TB cases, confirmed by smear microscopy and/or solid culture and/or liquid culture, showed at least one positive LAM-ELISA result. This 50.7 per cent sensitivity of the LAM-ELISA was disappointingly low. The specificity of 87.8 % also fell far short of expectations.”
The LAM-ELISA detects lipoarabinomannan (LAM), a mycobacterium-specific lipopolysaccharide component of the bacilli’s cell wall.
In active mycobacterial disease, LAM is released into the blood and passes the renal barrier without major changes - suggesting that its detection in urine should be a reliable diagnostic indicator.
Urine can be easily obtained, and its collection is often more culturally accepted than the collection of sputum or blood samples.
The LAM-ELISA might not have fulfilled the requirements for a stand-alone diagnostic test for pulmonary tuberculosis, but the researchers speculate that it may still be of some use.
“In our opinion, further investigations are needed to elucidate if the LAM-ELISA, in this stage of development, is valuable as a supplemental tool for the diagnosis of HIV-associated TB. This seems particularly important, when taking into consideration that TB is one of the most important opportunistic infections of HIV patients and that the sensitivity of smear microscopy in immunocompromised patients is low,” they say. (ANI)
- A childhood free from tuberculosis (TB) - Jul 17, 2010
- Berlin 2010: TB, HIV and Lung Health: From research and innovation to solutions - Nov 02, 2010
- Novel method to quickly detect active TB in smear-negative patients - Sep 23, 2009
- Sputum test best to detect TB: Azad - Sep 02, 2011
- False diagnosis of TB in HIV patients is fatal - May 17, 2010
- Standard re-treatment regimen for TB 'failing' in developing world - Mar 16, 2011
- 90-minute TB test not a game changer for India - Aug 29, 2011
- Giant rats detect TB more accurately than commonly used techniques - Dec 15, 2010
- Why is extra-pulmonary TB not a public health priority in India? - Sep 20, 2009
- New test top diagnoseTB proves effective, convenient - Sep 02, 2010
- Scientists 'one step closer' to predictive blood test for TB - Aug 19, 2010
- Awareness programmes mark World Tuberculosis Day in Delhi - Mar 24, 2011
- Urine test can detect tuberculosis, say Delhi scientists - Aug 05, 2011
- India battles staggering tuberculosis burden (March 24 is World TB Day) - Mar 23, 2011
- Central team to probe drug resistant TB cases in Mumbai - Jan 17, 2012
Tags: bacilli, diagnosis of hiv, diagnostic test, hiv patients, liquid culture, ludwig maximilians university, munich germany, mycobacterial disease, nimr, opportunistic infections, pulmonary tb, pulmonary tuberculosis, reither, sputum, supplemental tool, tb cases, tuberculosis tb, university college london, university college london uk, university of munich